Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei because they belong to the top of the three countries among the ge

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei because they belong to the top of the three countries among the generals, Liu Bei Guan Yu Zhang Fei Peach Garden Three Jieyi, where the world's strongest and courageous, often used to Guan Yu Zhang Fei comparisons, the following share Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful 1

From the actual performance, Guan Yu is significantly stronger than Zhang Fei.

Guan Yu seems to be lifted up in the play, but if you compare the history, you will find that all the performance of Guan Yu in the play is not as wonderful as the history. In the fifth year of Jian'an, Cao's army and Yuan's army fought at Baima, and Guan Yu, who had been treated so well by Cao Cao, said, "I want to repay Cao Cao for what he has done".

In the Battle of Baima, Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang looked down on everything, and Guan Yu saw the right time, and Zhang Liao led the army to rush into the army, "Yu saw Liang's banner cover, and his horse stabbed Liang in the midst of the crowd, and chopped his head off, and Shao's generals couldn't take it on, and then the siege of Baima was lifted". Chopping Yanliang this matter, only a few dozen words, but the next time there is such an unprecedented performance, it will be more than 400 years later.

Every enemy has a prima donna who shines in and out to boast the crowd, the king of Qin always ordered Qin Qiong to take it, jumping horses and guns stabbed in the crowd, and nothing is as good as the will.

Guan Yu horse stabbed Liang in the crowd, Qin Qiong jumped on the horse and stabbed the enemy general in the crowd, no wonder Qin Qiong always used and Guan Yu than. After Qin Qiong, the performance of the ten thousand army array chopping is rare, thousands of years of history, the performance can be as Guan Yu and Qin Qiong, extremely rare.

Guan Yu has such a performance, Zhang Fei is a bit inferior. The most majestic performance in Zhang Fei's life was the retreat at Chang Ban Po. Cao Cao south of Jingzhou, "personally led five thousand horsemen, a day and a night line 300 miles, chasing Liu Bei in Dangyang, Chang Ban", the five thousand people was Zhang Fei roared back, and Zhang Fei's men were only twenty cavalry, "the first Lord heard Cao Gong pawns to abandon his wife to go, Zhang Fei will be twenty riders refused to go back! ".

Of course, Zhang Fei retreated from the army, not only because he was brave, but also because Cao's army is not clear about the reality behind Zhang Fei, in addition, Cao's army's main purpose is not to fight with Zhang Fei, but to kill Liu Bei and other reasons. But if Zhang Fei is not the one standing on the bridge, I'm afraid he can't roar back the Cao army.

Therefore, in terms of actual performance, Guan Yu is clearly stronger than Zhang Fei. Although Zhang Fei was able to yell back at the enemy, he didn't have a direct battle with Cao's army, so there is no way to say that Zhang Fei was able to take the head of the enemy in the midst of ten thousand soldiers.

In addition to personal intimidation, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are not on the same level when it comes to generalship and marshalship. The first time I saw this, I was in the middle of a long journey, and I was able to get to the bottom of it, and I was able to get to the bottom of it. Among the five generals of Cao Wei, Zhang Liao was in Hefei town of Jiangdong, Zhang He was in Hanzhong town of Shu Han, all of them could not get out of the way, and Le Jin was dead, leaving Yu Bian and Xu Huang, and one of them was still captured by Guan Yu. Fancheng was besieged by Cao Ren, the most fierce of Cao's army, so that Cao Cao had to fight with Xiahou Dun, who was supposed to be in his twilight years, "Jian'an 24 years, Cao Cao's army grinding bei, called Xiahou Dun often with the same load". Even so, Guan Yu was able to encircle Cao Ren, capture Yu Ban, decapitate Pound, and nearly defeat Xu Huang at a place name north of Fancheng. This kind of influence at the level of a vassal king is not found in Zhang Fei.

The most successful battle in Zhang Fei's life was the repulse of Zhang He in Hanzhong, "Cao Cao left Zhang He to guard Hanchuan, and Zhang Fei refused for fifty days, Zhang Fei rate of elite soldiers ten thousand people, invited Zhang He's army to engage in battle from the other way, the mountain pass is narrow, before and after can not be rescued, Zhang Fei then broke Zhang He. Zhang He abandoned his horse, ° and more than ten men under his command led back to Nanzheng."

Why is Zhang Fei's battle gold? Because his opponent is even Zhu Geliang are afraid of Zhang He, "Zhang He knowledge of the changes, good at camp formation, expect the battle situation terrain, nothing like a plan, since Zhu Geliang are afraid of it." Nevertheless, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu are still not at the same level.

The victory of Hanzhong, Zhang Fei is the identity of the vanguard of the minions of the combat, its regimentation is far less powerful than Guan Yu in Jingzhou, at best, and later Zhuge Liang out of the Qishan when Zhao Yun a level. "Shu Han Jianxing six years in the spring, Zhuge Liang Yang sound by the oblique valley to take the eyebrow, so that Zhao Yun, Deng Zhi for the army of suspicion", Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition when Zhao Yun, is alone in charge of an army, in the battlefield with the army commander Zhuge Liang refused to fight a few hundred miles away from the battlefield.

This ability to stand alone is the watershed between generalship and marshalship. Zhang Fei Hanzhong defeat Zhang He, the real unique is the rear of Liu Bei, and no backstage do support the great victory, in Zhang Fei's life have never had. Therefore, from the evaluation point of view, Guan Yu also exceeded Zhang Fei, so Guan Yu is stronger than Zhang Fei on the whole.

At the end of the Han Dynasty, the most similar to this situation with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei was Cao Wei's Cao Ren and Zhang Liao. Cao Ren was basically equal to Guan Yu, and Zhang Liao was basically equal to Zhang Fei. After the defeat at Red Cliff, Cao Cao retreated to the north and ordered Cao Ren to guard Jiangling. During his one-year stay in Jiangling, Cao Ren fully demonstrated his "Cao Da Sima's courage" and his ability to stand on his own.

At that time, Zhou Yu led tens of thousands of troops to besiege Jiangling, Cao Ren's subordinate Niu Jin went to battle, but was besieged by Zhou Yu's army, at this time, Cao Ren personally led a dozen cavalrymen to rush into the enemy army to rescue Niu Jin and others, "Cao Ren put on his armor and mounted a horse, and will be dozens of strong soldiers to ride out of the city to go to the thieves for more than a hundred paces, and rushed into the thieves' encirclement, and then Niu Jin and others, and then came out, and the rest of them did not come out, Cao Ren was still straight to break out of the, and pulled out Niu Jin soldiers, and killed several people. Cao Ren was not all out, Cao Ren again straight back to the raid, pulled out the cattle gold soldiers, and killed several people, the thieves are back."

In addition to being as brave as Guan Gong, Cao Ren's ability to stand alone is also superb. Cao Cao has been fighting for more than 30 years, and Cao Ren has basically been opening up a second battlefield, working with Cao Cao in a similar manner as a "collaborator".

For example, when Cao Cao's forces rebelled against Ma Chao, Cao Ren took time out to quell the rebellion. After Cao Cao took Hebei, he spent most of his time in Yecheng, leaving the south largely in Cao Ren's hands. Cao Cao did not personally take part in the Wancheng Incident or the Hou Yin Rebellion, and Cao Ren took care of all of them on his own. The only time Cao Cao personally helped Cao Ren was during Guan Yu's Northern Expedition.

Cao Ren is Guan Yu, and Zhang Liao is Zhang Fei. The difference between Zhang Liao and Cao Ren is the difference between a general and a commander. Zhang Liao's whole life, almost never had the experience of being on his own, he always participated in the war as a deputy general, even when he was in the mighty Hefei. When Cao Cao attacked Xuzhou, Zhang Liao followed Cao Cao from Minister Chang, and when Cao Cao pacified Hebei, Zhang Liao was also from Minister Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang

When he and Cao Cao ****ed, he was always by Cao Cao's side or not too far away. Later, when Cao Cao ordered Zhang Liao to guard Hefei, he was not on equal footing with the duo of Li Dian and Le Jin, who were able to mobilize Zhang Liao because Le Jin had a higher rank than Zhang Liao.

But Zhang Liao was also comparable to Zhang Fei in terms of bravery. Hefei battle, Zhang Liao rate of eight hundred warriors rushed into Sun Quan 100,000 army, from the morning to noon, in and out, and survived, "Zhang Liao night selection of fierce soldiers, got eight hundred people, Pingdan, Zhang Liao armor with halberd, the first to board the trap, kill dozens of people, left and right, straight ahead of the rush, surrounded by the open, dozens of Zhang Liao under the banner of the people came out of the rest of the crowd called out, said: 'General abandoned me! General abandoned me! Zhang Liao returned to the siege, pulling out the rest of the crowd." This performance is nothing less than Cao Ren's performance in saving Niu Jin in Jiangling.

Overall, Shu Han does not have a lot of talent, except for Zhu Geliang, Guan Yu and Jiang Wei, very few people can hold their own. In contrast, Cao Wei has a lot of talent, not to mention Cao Cao, Cao Ren and Cao Hong in the early stage, Cao Zhen in the middle stage, and Sima Yi and Zhang He in the late stage. And there was no shortage of handsome talents in Wu either, with Zhou Yu in the early stages, Lu Su in the middle stages, and `Lu Meng and Lu Xun in the later stages. But there were never more than 15 great marshals in the whole of the three kingdoms at the end of the Han Dynasty combined.

It is worth noting that Liu Bei did not show handsome talent in his life, and before he met Zhuge Liang, he used the army for 24 years, no matter how big or small battles, almost every battle must be defeated. Leaders to rescue Tao Qian, lost to Cao Cao, and Liu Pai in Runan attacked Cao Cao, and lost to Cao Ren, into the battle of Luocheng, if there is no Pang Tong planning, Liu Bei himself can not do anything, the battle of Hanzhong, Liu Bei's only solo victory

The last intimidation of the battle, Liu Bei's life is the biggest personal battle, but also failed, so that Liu Bei in fact, will not be able to use the army, which is also a lot of people analogize him with Liu Bang, he can unite people. According to the Three Kingdoms Chronicle, (Zhang) Fei is stronger and more powerful than Guan.

Zhang Fei was one of the best generals in the Three Kingdoms era. When it comes to bravery, he once led a handful of elite cavalry to scare off a large number of Cao troops chasing Liu Bei; when it comes to strategy, he once released Yan Yan in righteousness, clearing a large obstacle for Liu Bei's capture of Xichuan; and when it comes to battle achievements, he once defeated Zhang He, a famous general of Cao Wei. Zhang Fei was an important official of Shu Han. His last official title was Che Cavalry General, and he received the title of Colonel of Si Li, and was promoted to the title of Marquis of Xixiang;

His two daughters were successively the empresses of Shu Han; and one of his grandchildren was an official of the Shangshu (Minister of the Shang Dynasty), and he finally died in battle with Zhuge Liang's son at Mianzhu. Zhang Fei's management style, tended to be strict, even harsh, and was eventually killed by his own subordinates as a result.

Historically, Guan Yu was indeed a bearded man, and Zhuge Liang wrote to Guan Yu, "I'm not as proud of his beard as he is of his own" precisely because of Guan Yu's beautiful beard. Historical Guan Yu is indeed a beautiful bearded man, Zhu Geliang wrote to Guan Yu "is not yet and the beard of the outstanding Yiqun also" precisely because of the beauty of Guan Yu's beard. Historically, Guan Yu was known by Cao Wei as the enemy of ten thousand people and the only famous general. He was also known as the General of Bear and Tiger by the Eastern Wu. Chen Shou called the style of the national scholar, for the world of tiger ministers.

Historically, the flooding of seven armies was real, the healing of bones was real (but not by Hua Tuo), the friendship with Zhang Liao and Xu Huang was real, and Cao Cao's desire to move the capital because of his prowess in China was real. It's also true that Guan Yu was captured by Cao Cao and forced to surrender, then returned to Liu Bei after beheading Yan Liang. In later times, Guan and Zhang were the best in terms of bravery. At the end of the Jin Dynasty, there was a fierce general named Chen An who held a seven-foot sword in his left hand and a spear in his right hand, and was known as Guan Yu and Zhang. That is to say, Guan Yu holding a big sword is not impossible.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is powerful 3

In fact, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei two people are in order to follow Liu Bei and come together, at the beginning of the period Zhang Fei and Guan Yu joined Liu Bei to stop the army of volunteers, and participated in the battle with the Yellow Turban Army. When Liu Bei realizes that Zhang Fei and Guan Yu have extraordinary skills, the three of them become close friends. Later, Liu Bei told Zhang Fei and Guan Yu about his identity and ambition, and they immediately decided to follow Liu Bei, and the three of them also became brothers, which is the very famous "Three Brothers in the Peach Orchard".

In the chaos of the world, there is nothing else to do, like Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, not much identity background if you look for a vassal army to join, it can only be cannon fodder. So the starting point of the two is considered to be a good choice, hitching a ride with a lord like Liu Bei.

Historically, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's feelings are also very good, the two have almost no conflict, and Zhang Fei is also very biased to take care of Guan Yu, the general back of the things are Zhang Fei to do. Zhang Fei is a butcher, unlike Liu Bei and Guan Yu as literate, so this is Zhang Fei's most disadvantageous place, but Zhang Fei in the battlefield is indeed invincible, just rely on the roar will be able to scare off the enemy.

Zhang Fei's exploits in the Three Kingdoms are far less colorful than Guan Yu's, and his death was a bit of a fiasco, as he was killed by his own men. So Zhang Fei's status in the Three Kingdoms is really low, and Liu Bei will always still treat Guan Yu as his most trusted person.

Guan Yu can be regarded as the first general of Shu Han, warm wine beheading Hua Xiong, over five passes to cut six generals, flooding seven armies, killing Yan Liang, shocking China, this writing is Guan Yu's life's proudest achievements. Guan Yu not only personal strength is not weak, but also know the art of war, in fact, compared with Zhuge Liang Guan Yu's master of arms talent will be more outstanding. And Guan Yu's self-learning ability is also very strong, often at night to see the military book late at night, this spirit is also Zhang Fei did not.

So over time, the status of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei was naturally pulled apart, and Liu Bei would have reused Guan Yu more. That's why Liu Bei was so excited when he learned that Guan Yu had died, and vowed to kill Wu to avenge Guan Yu's death, and Liu Bei, who has always been calm, was enraged.

This comparison, we should also understand that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the end who is stronger, single combat Zhang Fei lead, but Guan Yu is a leader of the characters. So the descendants of the evaluation of Guan Yu will be higher, but the shortcomings of Guan Yu is too proud, character strong general people will feel Guan Yu is not too good to get along with, but also because of this character leads to Sun Quan determined to kill Guan Yu. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's death is actually not very good, but this is the real history, the hero will never end well.