The two variety shows "I am a singer" and "The Voice of China", which one do you think is better?

The two variety shows, if according to the effect brought by the discovery of newcomers, it should be the good voice is better, if according to the quality of the songs then undoubtedly the singer is better, the following we analyze from all aspects.

"The Voice of China" Battle stage, PK two people as well as the song is the tutor's own choice, the tutor can control the gap between the strength of the two people, the bias of the road, the PK players "reasonable choice". The songs are chosen by the contestants themselves, but the mentor still decides who will fight with whom, the same principle as above. 4 into 1, not to mention that, at this stage, the mentor to protect who has been very obvious, as long as the contestant does not have a big accident, the result is basically fixed. See Kim and Ping An.

What level of so-called "audience" the "I am a singer" invites is also evident, and it's impossible to be fair. Fooling the audience who do not know how to sing, do not need to sing how good, can rattle their low tears on the line. Hence the choice of songs rather than singing in the program. Whoever sings a song with a high note that "touches the soul", whoever sings a speculative "nostalgic classic", whoever does a "stunning" remix, whoever stays.

In fact, there is no absolutely fair competition system. In comparison, the competition of The Voice is not fair, but also acceptable, after all, the four mentors have been singing for more than 20 years, who will still be red, it can be seen at a glance, so we have to keep the one that can be the most topical and the best of the red man. There is no doubt.

There are many essential differences in sound processing between TV program production and song recording. The biggest problem in the transmission of a TV show is that it goes through different processing, the sound is lost a lot, and the people watching the TV show use any device you can think of (50 cents a pair of headphones at a roadside stand, to tens of thousands of hifi headphones, from square dance stereos to tens of thousands of dollars of home theater...) to listen to the sound. So the biggest goal in the production of TV programs is to allow users to hear the best possible sound on a limited number of devices, and the signals must conform to the standards and specifications for broadcast television transmission.

That's why one of the main characteristics of The Voice of China video is that it's "middle of the road". That's my personal feeling. And I'm a singer's voice is a bit more complex. Favoritism is still up to the individual. The production of The Voice of China should put a lot of emphasis on the singer's own vocals, with all the other accompaniments. So the vocals are clear no matter what. As a singer, the emphasis on vocals is not as excessive as on The Good Voice of China, which results in better results than The Good Voice of China sounds if your headphones sound great, but maybe not if you're listening to it on laptop speakers. That's just my personal feeling, of course.

Let's just say that the industry of music directors for The Voice of China and I Am A Singer should be a godsend. Though to cut to the chase, it's also the position of Mr. Jin Shaogang and Mr. He Biao who have been building up their skills over the years. Also thank them for bringing us such a program.