How to write the opinions of review experts? I believe many people still don’t understand it. In order to enhance everyone’s understanding, today the editor has compiled relevant sample essays on this issue. Friends in need can refer to it!
p>The final result or score is given based on strengths and weaknesses, and the review comments may be considered separately. As the name suggests, review opinions are to first point out the strengths and weaknesses of the other party, then give the final result or score based on the strengths and weaknesses, and finally give the other party some guidance and suggestions as an expert.
The appraisal experts must be highly responsible and realistic, and make appropriate and fair evaluations based on the actual level of the representative work and the declared professional and technical positions.
If the evaluation opinions during the bid evaluation process can be led by the team leader, all judges can discuss and write them together. If it is the work evaluation of the review expert, it will be issued by the tenderer or agency.
Sample review opinions of the expert group:
The expert review opinions on the "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form for the Technical Transformation Project of Fenshuiling Water Plant of xx Water Co., Ltd." were approved by the Jinan Municipal Development and Reform Commission. Entrusted by Jinan Zhihua Consulting Co., Ltd. in accordance with the State Council's "Decision on Strengthening Energy Conservation Work" (Guofa [20xx] No. 28) and the National Development and Reform Commission Order (20xx No. 6) "Energy Savings Assessment and Assessment of Fixed Asset Investment Projects" Review the requirements of the Interim Measures.
Organize experts in electrical, water supply and drainage, energy management and other fields to review the "Energy Savings Assessment Report Form for Technical Transformation Project of Fenshuiling Water Plant of Jinan Quancheng Water Co., Ltd." ( (hereinafter referred to as "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form") conducted a letter review.
In the spirit of science, objectivity, fairness and responsibility, the experts carefully reviewed this "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form" and formed the following review opinions:
1. Basis of Assessment
p>1. It is strictly prohibited to adopt “xx” related planning outlines.
2. Update expired and obsolete standards, such as: "Code for Design of Urban Sewage Reuse" adopts GB50335-20xx "Code for Design of Wastewater Recycling Engineering"; update "Code for Design of 3-110kv High Voltage Distribution Device" to adopt GB50060-20xx version.
3. Delete standards and specifications not covered by this report, such as: "General Rules for Preparing Feasibility Study Reports and Preliminary Design Energy Saving Chapters (Chapter) of Fixed Asset Investment Projects" (Q/CNPC64-20xx).
2. Energy supply conditions at the project location
The specific transformer and distribution station unit that supplies power to the water plant, its distance and orientation from the plant area, and its power supply capacity, existing Load, indicating whether the supply conditions meet the energy demand for later operation of the project.
3. Process flow and technical solutions
1. For reconstruction and expansion projects, the original process and technical solutions should be explained, but the content of this section is mainly about the transformed process flow and technical solutions. The impact of technical solutions on energy consumption must be added. Relevant content must be added;
2. There is a large elevation difference between the east and west of the project site. The "Energy Saving Report Form" should supplement the plan and description of the project's original and new water purification facilities. Elevation layout plan, analyzing how to use natural height differences to reduce energy consumption measures and their effects.
It also explains how to deal with the relationship between the original facilities and the new facilities, so as to achieve energy saving and consumption reduction requirements as much as possible while maintaining normal operations during the project construction period.
4. Main energy-consuming processes, energy-consuming equipment, and auxiliary production systems:
1. Review the annual running time of the production process and improve the annual power consumption calculation process of the main electrical equipment.
2. Supplement the water production rate data of the filter membrane, compare it with the same industry, and conduct advanced analysis.
3. For membrane filters that consume large amounts of power, it is recommended to add monitoring and control facilities to determine reasonable power usage conditions.
4. The calculation statistics of power consumption of main water pumps are incomplete, and missing equipment should be supplemented.
5. Supplement the energy consumption indicators of industrial added value and industrial added value per 10,000 yuan, and conduct a comparative analysis with relevant provincial and municipal energy consumption indicators.
6. Make it clear that the heating method of the project is central heating or self-installed air-conditioning heating, and calculate the actual annual power consumption of air-conditioning operation.
7. Supplement water-saving measures and increase water reuse rate.
V. Analysis and evaluation of energy-saving technical measures and management measures:
1. This project consumes large amounts of energy, and an energy management system must be established.
2. Increase the configuration of energy measurement devices such as energy statistics and monitoring for this project.
VI. Others:
1. Please use the "Interim Measures for Energy Conservation Assessment and Review of Fixed Asset Investment Projects" (National Development and Reform Commission Order No. 6) to prepare the "Energy Conservation Assessment Report Form" According to the requirements, the corresponding content of "overall energy consumption indicators (energy consumption per unit product, unit consumption of major processes, energy consumption per unit building area, energy consumption per unit output value or added value, etc.)" should be added to the report table.
2. In the analysis of project energy efficiency indicators, make a horizontal comparison of energy consumption indicators with similar water plant projects in Shandong Province and Jinan City as much as possible to analyze the energy efficiency level of the project.
3. The report analyzes and evaluates the energy consumption of each unit of the project based on the improved and adjusted energy consumption. The content of the project's "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form" is relatively complete and the depth basically meets the requirements. After review, in principle it passed the energy-saving review of Jinan Quancheng Water Co., Ltd.'s "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form for Fenshuiling Water Plant Technical Transformation Project".
For problems existing in the "Energy Saving Assessment Report Form", please report to the preparation unit and the construction unit to make further modifications and improvements based on the expert review opinions, and then submit them to the review unit for another review.
xx Consulting Co., Ltd.
xx, xx, xx
More about the writing and production of tender documents for engineering/service/procurement categories to increase the bid winning rate. You can click on the official website customer service at the bottom for free consultation: /#/?source=bdzd