Qinyuan coal mine roof accident trapped 5 people all killed, is the rescue is not timely or simply can not rescue?

According to, the information shows that the roof plate accident ? refers to the accidental fall of the roof plate in the process of underground coal mining, causing casualties, equipment damage, production termination and other accidents. It is one of the main common disasters in coal mine production. 

At 7:50 p.m. on Aug. 5, a roof slab accident occurred at the head of the 3102 tape trench face of the 3 coal seam of Shanxi Qinyuan Fenghuangtai Coal Co Ltd, resulting in five people being trapped. At 15:07 on August 8, rescuers searched and rescued the remains of the fifth trapped person. So far, all five trapped people in this roof accident were found, and all of them were killed. The site search and rescue work is over.

So here we can see that this mining accident, in fact, is down the channel working face, accidental fall . Will people directly buried alive. In other words, the probability is that as long as these five staff on the ground at the time, there was no opportunity to escape directly.

According to the propaganda department of Shanxi province Qinyuan county party committee news, the beginning of the mine disaster, Changzhi city and Qinyuan county governments have organized geological, gas experts to set up a technical expert group, deployed 134 people emergency rescue team, carrying 100 sets of hydraulic pillars, 20 tons of filling materials and other related materials rushed to the rescue. Meanwhile, a medical team of 27 people, five ambulances and a helicopter were dispatched to the scene.

And from the time of the accident, from the accident occurred body was found, a **** less than 72 hours, and we know that the golden rescue time is 72 hours, so this is to say, perished mining workers, there is no way in the golden 72 hours to get help, therefore, they were killed, can not be ruled out the possibility of rescue due to untimely. But in my humble opinion, I also think that mining workers instantly by the disaster, I'm afraid that at that time, simply how many opportunities, can get to survive. So, Qinyuan coal mine roof accident trapped 5 people, simply can not rescue is not impossible, and the above is my guess, because the specific cause of the accident, and then did not come out, Shanxi Province has been initiated to raise the level of the investigation is also just started.