The word "doctor" has two meanings at first: people+medical skills = people with medical skills = doctors.
"Medical skill" or "medical ethics" must be based on "people with medical skills", that is to say, medical skill is the most important foundation of this discipline. People without medical skills can only be called "virtuous people" or "compassionate people" Obviously, medical ethics can only be based on medical skills.
As a man with medical skills, even bad people can cure patients; But a good man without medical skills, even a moral model, can't cure any patient. Therefore, as long as the treatment is the purpose, then medical skills are like the foundation. Medical ethics without medical skills must be castles in the air. You can't convince people with virtue, can you? Can a "God" who loves everyone help cure diseases? No, so we went to church on Sunday and got sick and went to the hospital.
The essence of medical ethics requires doctors to love patients and treat medical treatment with higher standards, which is the sublimation of personal morality, but it is not a necessary element. Because there are always good people and bad people in this world, you can never ask for only good people in this industry. To judge a qualified doctor, we should first base ourselves on the fact that he is an ordinary person, not an angel's standard, nor the devil's character.
I hate this debate that incites and demonizes doctors without understanding the nature of contradictions. There is a real world in my space. If you want to see the world outside the ivory tower, go and see for yourself.
The image of the devil in white is really popular with people. Are you interested in hearing the devil's lies? Lies may be more shocking than the reality you agree with.
In a demonized industry, disputes emerge one after another, and doctors need to protect themselves. Now it's not just the doctor who feels uncertain, so the examination needs to leave an objective evidence to prove that I'm not mistaken. This is the result of abnormal medical environment. The high cost of physical examination is only paid by patients.
Secondly, hospitals need to earn 98% of their own operating expenses, and the national average investment is less than 5%, which is actually less than 2%. Wages, bonuses, equipment and Gai Lou all need to be earned. Therefore, it is best to treat hospitals as enterprises, not welfare homes, so as to understand hospitals. (Attachment: Except for a few "super-profitable" hospitals, official data show that from 2000 to 2007, the average operating profit rate of hospitals in China was 4.42% in 2002 and 0.64% in 2006. In 2007, the profit rate of public hospitals was 3.02%. Therefore, hospitals are not as profitable as you think. In fact, profits flow to parasites attached to the medical system.
Some patients I have seen have no money for treatment, some are starved to death by their families, and some are left in bed to rot and become maggots. Over the years, I have become accustomed to the fact that there is no worst, only worse. I never intended to be an angel. I'm just a mortal. I want to be a conscientious person and pursue a happy life. People who regard doctors as angels are doomed to be disappointed, because they are just human like you. The devil in your eyes may be an "angel" who showed brilliant humanity when SARS and earthquake came. But in the face of poverty and life pressure, he will give up moral standards for his family. A good system will prevent bad doctors from making mistakes, and a wrong system will tempt good doctors to commit crimes.
China people's requirements for medical ethics are close to God, which is totally unreasonable. What's more, patients are not the only victims, but doctors are also human beings, and they need to survive, develop and reflect their own values. It is a kind of sorrow to take humiliation as a normal life. The demonized medical industry is no safer than the police. You have heard that several industries will be forced to jump off buildings and be hacked to death.
Even a person is not immune. I believe that even under this system, you will go with the flow. I can't change the system. I can only hope that most people will wake up and have enough strength to change the system.
The essence of debate is to see the essence clearly and cultivate a pair of eyes to see through things. Under this system, not only patients are victims, but also doctors are victims. At the top of the biological chain are rulemakers and parasites attached to this system.
This kind of argument has no other effect than continuing to demonize doctors, intensifying social contradictions and intensifying some people's delusions of persecution.