What happened to Guan Yu's bone-scraping treatment? What does Guan Yu rely on to endure down?

Guanyu opened the knife to scrape the bones to poison also do not play anesthesia, Guan Yu in the end is relying on what to endure down? I believe that many friends will have such a question, is not afraid of the pain of Guan Yu fainted over it. Not over hard to explain, there are two points can be explained, one is Guan Yu did not play anesthesia, but drank a lot of wine, ancient wine brewing process may not be very mature, so the degree of wine will be relatively high, people are drunk is also equivalent to playing anesthesia. Secondly, because Guan Yu's entire right arm was wounded by a poisoned arrow, has lost consciousness, open the knife to feel no pain that nature is also no need for anesthesia. Of course, these two points of knowledge speculation, the real reason may only Guan Yu himself know.

Many partners have a question, is the Three Kingdoms period really have anesthetic this thing? According to ancient books, Hua Tuo then invented ? The first anesthetic is directly on the earliest anesthetics. is directly on the earliest anesthetic, but also Hua Tuo specifically for surgery invented anesthesia. It was also the first anesthetic invented by Hua Tuo specifically for surgical operations. Hua Tuo's biography recorded: ? If the disease is knotted inside, the needle and medicine can not be reached, is to make the first wine to take the hemp boiling san, both drunken and unaware, because of the router through the back of the abdomen, extracting and cutting the accumulation. If you look at it this way, it is true that there were already medicines with anesthesia effect at that time, but when Hua Tuo died, he did not record the detailed formula of Ma Bo San, so the prescription was lost. So about the authenticity of the hemp boiling powder can not be guaranteed, after all, in 2000 years ago to invent anesthesia medicine is still very remarkable.

But in fact to Guan Yu scraping the life is not Hua Tuo, according to the official history of Hua Tuo is in 208 years passed away, and Guan Yu arm injury is in ten years later, the two things are too far away from time. But the strange thing is, whether in the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" or "Three Kingdoms", have done some exaggerated treatment of Hua Tuo, many cases seem to be impossible things, but in the official history of the record. It shows that Hua Tuo's status is still very high in the hearts of the ancients, and people are also willing to take help Hua Tuo to make him a legend. Probably because the ancients very much hope that there can be a famous doctor like Hua Tuo came out, after all, the average life expectancy of the ancient people is short the biggest enemy is the disease, may be a small typhoid fever will take the lives of countless people.

Guan Yu bone scraping in the "Three Kingdoms" is also recorded, the general process and the play is almost the same, but Guan Yu injury is not the right arm but the left arm, and after the doctor is not Hua Tuo, and did not record the life of this in the end is who, the other aspects of the difference is not much. So even if Guan Yu did not scrape the bone so exaggerated, but certainly also suffered some treatment, after all, the ancient times, no matter whether it is the medical equipment or the environment is very simple. Maybe a careless infection can also cause fatal injuries.

For Guan Yu and Hua Tuo, this story has accomplished them and made them better known to future generations. But in reality, there must have been more than one famous doctor in the Three Kingdoms, it's just that Hua Tuo cured more illnesses and had a lot of seniority, and was eventually unjustly killed by Cao Cao, which made him known to so many people. Of course there does exist some randomness, but there is no need to pursue the authenticity too seriously, just as a hot-blooded novel to see it.