Goodwill lies debate collection of 10
Goodwill lies debate 1Life needs goodwill lies I do not agree with the positive side of the point of view, I think that life needs goodwill lies, because the back of this kind of lie refracted a kind of goodness, a good, it is indispensable to life in the flavoring agent. Lies are indeed deceptive. But the good intention of the lie is our indispensable, if there is no good intention of the lie, some people hide the family's condition, let them feel better, so that their condition can make them recover quickly. Besides,this time we also learnt don't "starve that horse" and "the only listener" who can say that professor and new year are liars? Do they lie to other people for themselves? No, no! The valuable thing about this well-intentioned lie is that the deception is well-intentioned. It reflects not hypocrisy, but goodness, kindness. Have you not been touched by their lies? There are also the following examples:
Some people because the parents at home can not afford to pay the tuition fees, it is due to labor and illness. The son then gave up the opportunity to study at the university, lying to his family. The son then gave up the opportunity to go to college and lied to his family. He hid from his family and secretly found a job.
Mary's child was born with no ears, so she was teased by her classmates, had no friends, and lived in loneliness and depression. The only solution was to find a suitable ear, and after a long struggle to find one, an operation was performed. The surgery was a success, and when she wanted to return the favor, her parents wouldn't tell her. His parents didn't tell her, and when his mother died, he realized that his ears belonged to his mother.
When the mother of a soldier who is on a mission in the field is terminally ill and dying, how much she wishes to see her son one last time. However, the son can not come back, can not for the old mother to do a little filial piety, take care of the son had to worry about the mother, he was very sorry. Before her mother left, she told her relatives: after she left, she told her son that her condition had stabilized, so that he could be at ease and do his best for the country, is such a lie an obstacle to honesty? Therefore, I insist: not only does the good faith lie not hinder the integrity, but also will greatly enhance the friendship between people and affection, social stability has indelible.
Goodwill lies debate 2"Ding bell?" The class bell rang, students have returned to the classroom, waiting for Mr. Lu's arrival. Today we have to "honesty and good faith lies" a debate, the debate has not yet begun, everyone took out last night to collect information on this topic, fist rubbing, stupid.
First of all, Mr. Lu let the positive side of the students out, a count of more than a dozen people, most of them are in favor of the opposite side, although the positive side of the people less, but they seem to be very confident, want to stage a "less than more" war, the debate has not yet begun, the whole classroom is filled with a strong smell of gunpowder.
The debate began, first by the positive side of the point of view: lies, lying is cheating, cheating is immoral, immoral things are not popular, these are from childhood, elders have been taught. Honesty is the traditional virtues of the Chinese people, while the lie is everyone's cover, even if the lie before the addition of the word "goodwill", is also a lie! Mr. Lu listened to the positive side of the debate and felt that it made sense, so he joined the positive side, but we on the negative side did not let it discourage us, and the class president, Chang Bawen, countered with an example: her grandmother, during a health check, found that there were two tumors growing in her body that looked like balls, so who would tell the truth to a loved one who was already in pain? For the sake of her grandmother, she decided to keep her mouth shut about the truth, but to use a well-intentioned lie to make her grandmother hopeful about the treatment, so that she could spend the rest of her life in a peaceful state of mind. Could this have gotten in the way of honesty! The audience has not yet been able to say a "good" word, the positive side and a rebuttal, usually like brothers and sisters of good friends now who do not let anyone, tit for tat, launched a heated debate war, but the results were not divided. Finally, Mr. Lu analyzed and summarized the debate: life, we must speak honesty, but sometimes, also need to lie with good intentions.
After this debate, the students gained a lot, both the positive and negative have a reason, in principle, to speak honesty, can not deceive others, but, in real life because of some reasons, so that we have to say lies, which is the so-called "goodwill lies", which is the starting point is good, is lying at the same time to achieve the goodwill to deceive, and the goodwill lies. When the good intention to deceive, and had to fabricate a lie.
Goodwill lies debate 3
Dear teachers, dear students:
Hello!
Lies are bad, but today, we add a word in front of it - well-intentioned. Then, its nature has changed radically. There is such a saying: a well-intentioned lie is beautiful. When we lie moderately for the happiness of others, the lie is changed into understanding, respect and tolerance.
For example, when a patient suffering from a terminal illness, was declared dead by the doctor, his relatives, will not directly tell him "your life can not be saved", "you will not live long" and so on. Although these words are true, who would be as cruel as a judge pronouncing a death sentence on a prisoner, telling the truth to a loved one who is already in pain. At this point, everyone will form a united front, shut up about the truth, and use well-intentioned lies to make the patient hopeful about the treatment, so that the patient in a peaceful state of mind to spend the rest of the year. Is this not right? If you were the patient's family, would you tell him the truth?
Good lies have the magical power to inspire you to make progress again and again, and to never give up on your dreams. Because the road ahead is completely illuminated with joy, and life is better for it.
Goodwill Lies Debate 4I. Debate process:
Debate begins
2. Announce the rules of the competition
3. Introduce judges and guests
4. Announce the topic of the debate
5. Introduction of the participants
7. Debate
8. Scoring by the judges
9. Audience participation in asking questions or expressing their own views
10. p>
1. Time Tips. During the debate, each side will be reminded by the timekeeper with a yellow card when there are 30 seconds of time remaining. When the time is full to show a red card to terminate the speech, speakers must stop speaking, or as a violation of the treatment.
2. The evidence is solid and sufficient, and the citation is appropriate.
3. Argumentative requirements based on facts, to the law as a criterion, logical clarity, concise and concise.
4. Attack and defense
(1) Attack and defense by the positive side of the second defense, alternating between positive and negative.
(2) The second and third defense of the positive and negative sides participate in the attack. The first defense of the positive and negative side to make a summary of the attack. For and against the second and third defense and must have a time as the offensive; defense by the offensive side of the arbitrary designation, not limited to the number of times. Attacking and defending sides must finish this round of attacking and defending alone, and cannot be replaced in the middle of the round.
(3) both sides must answer each other's questions, questions and answers should be concise and clear. Repeated questions and evasive questions will be deducted. In each round of defense, the attacked party may not ask questions, or points will be deducted. No question may be asked to affect the integrity of the other side's defense, and no long defense may be used to prevent the other side from asking questions. The moderator has the right to terminate a question or defense that exceeds the time limit.
(4) The first round of the offense and defense phase is completed with the players standing up. Both sides of the attack and defense of either party to take their seats as the completion of their side of the attack and defense, the other player in the limited time to play (speech or continue to ask questions).
(5) each round of attack and defense stage for 1 minute 30 seconds, the attacking and defending sides do not do their own time settings, the time remaining 30 seconds, to the yellow card prompts, when the time is full, show the red card to terminate the speech.
(6) four rounds of offensive defense stage is completed, first by the positive side of the first defense of the offensive summary and then by the negative side of the first defense for the team to make the offensive summary, time limit of 1 minute 30 seconds. Both sides of the attack and defense summary of the attack and defense phase of the situation and the content, strictly prohibited from the actual situation of the game of the memorandum.
5. Free debate. This round of debate, positive and negative debaters automatically take turns to speak, first any member of the positive side to stand up and speak, speak for the end of the speech that is the other side of the speech began to mark the time, the other side of the debaters must follow the speech, if there is a gap, the cumulative time as usual. There is no limit to the order in which the speakers of the same side may speak. If one side has run out of time, the other side may continue to speak or indicate to the Chairperson that it wishes to give up its speech. Free debate advocates active exchange, the important issue of avoiding the exchange of more than twice the party deducted points, for the other side has clearly answered the question is still pestering, appropriate deduction of points.
6. Conclusion. Both sides of the debate should be summarized for the overall form of the debate, detached from the actual, reciting the pre-prepared manuscripts, appropriate deduction.
7. Audience questions. The performance of the audience during the questioning stage is counted as part of the competition results. The questions raised by the audience will be answered only after they are judged valid by more than two judges. The audience is free to ask questions about their own problems, and each side will answer two questions raised by the audience, and both sides except the fourth defender will answer any of them. A question can be answered in no more than 1 minute and 30 seconds. If one of the debaters has not answered all the questions, the other debaters can supplement their answers. (The debaters of each team can concentrate the information on their own cards for reference when they speak, but they can't read out the prepared script or show the pre-prepared charts or word boards, and the team members can provide each other with clues for their speeches during the free debates).
Instructions for the competition
1. The scoring staff will be on the opposite side of each team, using yellow or red cards to indicate the time. There will be a "timer" to indicate the time. In the various stages of the game, raise the yellow card to indicate the time reminder, raise the red card to indicate the completion of the debater with time, the debater must stop speaking and immediately sit down, or discretionary deduction of points.
2. In the course of the debate, the contestants can refer to the information prepared in advance (such as cards, etc.), but may not read the information time for 10 seconds in a row. Otherwise, group and individual points will be deducted as appropriate.
3. Each game of the team members shall be unified clothing, specific by the team to decide.
4. The teams must arrive at the venue within half an hour before the start of the game, in order to facilitate the organizers of the unified arrangements for the event, so that the preparation of the game can be carried out smoothly.
Requirements
Each team consists of five debaters, one of whom is an alternate. Requirements of the debaters articulate, quick thinking, well-prepared before the game, the chairman of the requirements: the appearance of the instrument is upright, articulate, cheerful and generous. Each team consists of a defense, second defense, third defense, fourth defense, composed of four people, through a defense speech, both sides of the attack, a defense summary, free debate, summary statement, the audience asked six links.
Grading Criteria
1. Sharp viewpoints, adequate argumentation, appropriate citations, thorough and rigorous analysis.
2. Fluent expression, accurate pronunciation, proper wording, clear hierarchy, and strict logic.
3. Sensitive response, strong rebuttal, tacit understanding, rich expression, dignified manner, elegant demeanor.
3. Kindness of lies debate debates
The positive point of view: people should be honest.
The opposite view: people sometimes have to tell some good lies.
Moderator: "Speak honesty and goodwill lies" debate began!
Positive main defense: we believe that people should be honest, as the saying goes, "honesty is the foundation of a person".
The opposite side of the main defense: we think that people can not rigidly keep honesty, in the necessary time should also be spreading good lies.
The second defense: the good faith lie is always a lie, into the ten thousand steps to say is just a "good faith" name, back ten thousand steps to say is still a lie, good faith lie is still a lie in the final analysis, just fade away the stone robe replaced with a brocade robe, but the lie is contrary to honesty no matter how to say, so we do not advocate lying, even if it is for the sake of other people's good. it is for the good of others.
The second defense: although the good faith lie is against the integrity, but its starting point is good, and then turn the topic to the positive and negative debaters, do not you have not lied? Have you never told a good lie?
The third defense: Yes! His body is not correct how to convince people!
The main defense: no matter what, the good intention of the lie is always a lie, there can not be an essential change, and honesty is the basic code of conduct, everything can not be contrary. Hasn't the counter-defense heard of the allusion to Liu Bang's covenant?
The main argument of the opposite side: honesty sometimes pierces the hearts of others, while a good lie can often appease the hearts of others. Just as an example, if a patient suffering from incurable diseases ask you what disease he has, but you relentlessly tell him to suffer from a terminal illness, then the patient will lose confidence in life, thus aggravating the condition, this time integrity may turn you into an indirect murderer; on the contrary, if you tell him just got a cold, then the patient will be optimistic, hard work or study, even when he is sick, he will not complain that you cheated the murderer. He will not complain that you have deceived him, but on the contrary, he will be grateful to you for the encouragement you have given him during this period of time, and this is when you are a good psychiatrist.
Moderator: this "honesty and good faith lies" debate went quite well, we also summarized their own views: in daily life, honesty is indispensable, but in some cases, good faith lies are also a good way to save others and their own out of danger.
Goodwill Lies Debate 5"Ding bell bell" out of class, I ran outside the classroom, breathing fresh air. At the same time and shifted his eyes to the playground, wow! There are so many people! Look, the first grade children are playing eagle catching chickens it ...... It's really crowded. This lively scene, can not help but remind me of yesterday's fierce debate...
Class is in session, the students rushed into the classroom, sat upright, and then took out their materials. Someone asked what material? Why take out materials? Right, you did not think of it! Today we are going to have a debate - "speaking honestly and good lies".
First, we started with a group scramble to select the most eloquent and strong debating students as group representatives. Our group scrambled to read, in fact, I do not want to go up, but I had to read. Arranged by the group leader, we tried to read one by one first. Then the group voted to decide. We all put our best foot forward to compete with others. Finally, through the group vote, I was elected, and I had nothing to say. After about 10 minutes, the group contested election was over.
I was the positive debater. There were the same number of debaters on the positive side as there were on the negative side: five. We were sitting in the first row under the podium. Our host is Lu Yueying. Lu Yueying used a loud and steady voice to speak out the opening speech "Classmates, today we are here to hold a debate on 'Honesty and Kindness Lies'." Just finished, the following warm applause rang out. "The following is for the pro and con sides to introduce themselves." ...... "Hello everyone, my name is Li Mengyang, and I'm from the Sixth Three Squadron." I nervously finished the first sentence of the debate. Since this was the first debate I had ever participated in my life, I was very nervous. "Let's start with the positive and negative sides presenting their points, starting with the positive side." Just finished, Wang Hai You will be very strong said "We have heard of the Analects of Confucius, the Book of Rites, the words: the people have no faith does not stand ...... I stood up and said "A lie is a lie, why add the word "goodwill" to it, it's just an excuse! This sentence is an exclamatory sentence, or a heavily emphasized sentence, so when I read it, I deliberately read the sentence very heavily ...... Once we had debated on the positive side. The opposing teammates also seemed to be well prepared. As expected, the opposing team's defense forcefully hit back at us. "In life, good lies are needed." Then she gave a powerful example. Of course, I didn't surrender, I caught her break and asked her "Nowadays, there are many professional killers who use good intentioned lies to cheat many people, how do you explain this?" Cai Yuanjie countered me again, this time she was still off script and did the actions while talking, which really impressed me. At that time, I really wanted to fight for our team's honor, but I had nothing to say. Finally, the host concluded: "honesty is the root of being human, but life needs good lies ......
After this debate, we did not win, but it made me bold enough to speak up in class.
Good Faith Lies Debate 6A "lie" is obviously something that is not true. Lying for different purposes will lead to very different results:
One out of the detriment of self-interest to deceive people with cunning and treacherous means, it is a malicious fraud, will inevitably lead to the decline of social morality and disorder.
Another kind of purpose in favor of others to hide the real situation, it is a good faith concealment, will make the feelings more harmonious, more harmonious society. Therefore, the difference between good faith concealment and bad faith fraud, from the motive to the result, should not be confused. When the poor mother to the only meal left to the children, while hiding the fact that they are still hungry, do you still want to accuse the good and noble mother love "dishonest"?
1, please note that the other side of the defense: a good lie as a correct and friendly way of life, lies depending on the nature of the difference between malicious fraud and concealment of good intentions, the two are not to be confused.
2. In the lesson "The Golden Hook", the old squad leader hid from the team that he only ate grass roots and fish spines, and told the team that he had already eaten the fish, does it mean that this also affects the integrity of the old squad leader? In the lesson "The Only Listener", my father and sister are very honest, and I play the violin like a sawhorse, but their honesty strikes me hard. The old man's "lie" restored my faith. Should the other side say that the old man was dishonest? It's the same in Don't Starve the Horse. And listen with your heart.
3, a little girl with leukemia in the late stages of her life when the doctor asked her what her biggest wish was, she said she wanted to go to Tiananmen Square to see the flag-raising ceremony of a dying girl's last wish doctors and parents which is not to meet the reason for it, but because of her home in the distant Xinjiang if to meet the requirements of the doctor is afraid of the girl can not withstand the journey's fatigue, so a by more than 20xx volunteers and doctors and the girl's family organization, the doctor said, the girl is the most important thing. Volunteers and doctors and the girl's family organized a collective fabrication of the lie began from the train to change to the tourist bus all the way from the station to the waiter to serve tea and even to the travelers to talk about are all intentionally arranged finally came to a school in the marching band accompanied by the sound of the national anthem the blind girl thought it really came to the longed-for Tiananmen Square when she saw her powerless to raise her small hand to the flag salute in the direction of when people present at the ceremony. When she saw her powerless hand raised her small salute to the direction of the national flag, the people present all shed tears this organized by more than 20xx collective lying action, you can say that their good faith lies have hindered the integrity of it?
On October 21st, our six (1) squadron conducted a debate on "honesty and good faith lies", and every student was particularly excited.
At the beginning, the positive side came to a downward spiral, Xiao He said; "A lie is a lie, even a well-intentioned lie is also a lie!" The opposite side is not afraid of him! I bravely stood up and refuted him, "Wrong! Lies depending on their essential differences, divided into malicious fraud and good faith concealment, the two can not be confused!" I continued to ask him rhetorically, "Take an example! When a poor mother leaves her only meal for her children, while concealing the fact that she is still hungry, do you still want to accuse the good and noble mother of dishonesty?" Each of the apologists on the positive side looked helplessly into my firm eyes, blushing and speechless. Defiantly Xiaohui stood up and said, "What you say . . is right, but when the children eat it, does the mother get to eat it? A well-intentioned lie can't have it both ways!" At this time the small full also stood up, said loudly: "the positive side, our side has made it clear that lies and well-intentioned lies can not be confused ......"
This debate makes me understand that lies are dishonest manifestations, but sometimes it is also necessary to moderately pull some well-intentioned
This debate has taught me that lies are a sign of dishonesty.
Goodwill lies debate 8
Students, teachers:
Good day to you all. People say that sincerity is the way of heaven; sincerity is the way of man. You can't be honest.
But now they are talking about what kind of goodness, goodwill lies. I think a lie is a lie, there is no such thing as good or evil, regardless of whether the lie is in a good starting point, beginning or a purpose. Some people say that the good lie is to help others, but I want to say, that is, for the good, and why lie, why need to lie.
Psychologists once said, do not easily lie, even if it is a well-intentioned lie. Because it is possible that a well-intentioned lie will not only not help people, but may also bring more harm.
For example: an old woman went to the hospital when she was checked out of liver cancer, in order not to let her son know, she prepared a well-intentioned lie. Then the old lady died, the neighbor in order not to let him sad, they made up another well-intentioned lie that the old woman went abroad for a break, but when the teenager knew the truth, he was so sad that he couldn't help himself, and all of a sudden jumped from the 29th floor of the sky, and in an instant, shattered his body.
These examples can tell us, do not easily lie, even if it is a good lie. Thought it can make your life a failure. Therefore, I think we must speak honesty, but also let a little more trust between people.
"Lies" are called "lies" because they are false, untrue, and deceitful words. If a person often has a lie in his mouth to deceive others, he will lose people's trust in the course of time. Just like the child in the article "the lying child", every day shouting "the wolf is coming" in order to seek excitement, happy, but when the wolf really comes, he only one person to face independently, to bear by himself, no matter how much shouting will not help, and there will be no one to help him again. No one will come to help him, because the people who may come to help him have already gotten used to his shouting, thinking that he is "teasing you" again, so it can be seen that the lie is in the way of honesty. But today, when we talk about "lies", there is a qualifier - good faith, and with this qualifier, the nature of the lie is fundamentally changed. "Goodwill lies" are people's good wishes for things, is the people's good heart of the dialog, is the people comfort each other a trace of warmth, is a kind of tenderness out of the bottom of people's hearts ...... who will not go to investigate the credibility of the degree, even if the Hearing goodwill lies people know is a lie, but also the same will go to try to believe, will not feel the hypocrisy of the liar, and sometimes also from the heart to appreciate it.
Our starting point:
First, a good lie is a lie out of good motives, in order to safeguard the interests of others for the purpose and starting point.
Second: a good lie is a way of being in the world, a reflection of the quality of thinking for others. A terminally ill patient's friends and relatives always use well-intentioned lies to minimize his condition and encourage him to cooperate with the doctor's treatment, and I believe that everyone here will not accuse them of dishonesty because of this, right?
Third: although the well-intentioned lie is a kind of lie, but we can not say that the lie must have hindered the integrity, to analyze the specific problems. The reason why honesty is respected by everyone is because it is good faith not to deceive, good faith lies on the surface, it seems to hinder the principle of honesty, but from the essential point of view, the reason why it exists, is because of speaking the truth is hindered by the principle of goodness.
Fourth: A world without lies is like an earth without dust. We agree that the fact that a well-intentioned lie does not impede honesty does not mean that we promote it, and that the key lies in the degree.
The first defense of the opposition: the following is our concluding statement of the goodwill lie is beautiful, this lie is not deception is not malicious. When we moderate some small lies for the happiness and hope of others, the lie that becomes understanding, respect and tolerance, and has the magical power, without any impurity. A good lie is a lie out of good intentions, a nourishment for life, and the driving force of faith. It makes people light up the fire of hope from the heart, and also makes people sure that there is love, trust and touch in the world! Kindness lies can make people find a reason to face life with a smile.
Kindness of the lie, is to give human spirituality, reflecting the emotional delicacy and maturity of thought, prompting people to be strong and persistent, can not help but go to work to fight, and finally overcame the fragile, desperate to survive. A well-intentioned lie can make a patient with a terminal illness come back from the dead, and can give others a ray of hope. A well-intentioned lie can restore a person's self-confidence, and sometimes it can save a person who is about to have a nervous breakdown. Obviously, well-intentioned lies do not hinder integrity. Goodwill lies can ignite the flame of hope, who can say it is not goodwill?
1, when a terminally ill patient, was sentenced to death by the doctor, his parents, loved ones, children, as well as all the loved ones, will not directly tell him: "life can not be saved", "up to how long can live in this world! " and so on. Although these are true, who would be as cruel as a judge sentencing a prisoner to death to tell the truth to a loved one who is already in pain. At this point, everyone will form a united front, keep their mouths shut about the truth, and use well-intentioned lies to make the patient hopeful about the treatment, so that the patient can spend the rest of his or her remaining years in a peaceful state of mind. Is it possible that this will hinder the integrity?
2, saw a TV report said an old mother had a kidney disease, if not kidney life will be threatened, then the eldest son stood up and asked for his mother to donate a kidney, which can hurt the old mother, the old mother strongly opposed to say that if so they might as well die. She had no choice but to wait for a kidney source that matched her conditions, but it was not easy to wait for such a kidney source. The son was afraid of delaying his mother's condition, so he talked with his family and tricked his mother. One of his young kidneys donated to the mother, after the success of the operation, the family is still hidden from the old mother, the most touching is the mother and son living in the next ward, the mother is not aware of when the mother wants to see the oldest son, the family just lied to her that the son went on a business trip, I was moved to tears after reading the report, friends is not such a lie hindered by the integrity of it?
3, here we come to an example, there is a student, he is not very good at long-distance running, but in a test, the teacher told him that the long-distance running faster than other students, and also said that he had the opportunity to represent the school to participate in the competition, told him to work hard, the student listened to the teacher's words are very excited, because has always thought that they do not have the talent of long-distance running, but he can represent the school to participate in the competition. The student was very excited after hearing the teacher's words, because he had always thought that he had no talent for long-distance running, but he could represent his school in the competition. From this day on, he really liked the long-distance running, and every day insisted on getting up to run, after a period of time, was not able to represent the school to participate in the competition, he was really selected.
4, there was a teacher, he spread a panic that he can give students predict the future: you may become a mathematician in the future, he can be a writer, that one has artistic talent ...... in the teacher's instruction, inculcation, encouragement and molding, the children become diligent and hard-working, know how to learn. A few years later, a large number of students with excellent results into the door of the university, the village is also famous. People think that the old teacher can pinpoint the future, can sense the future, in fact, the teacher's good intentions is a beautiful lie planted in the child's mind, like sowing a seed in the soil, will eventually flourish, blossom and bear fruit. Question: Q: When a child, who does not rhyme with the world, suddenly suffers a misfortune and loses his loved ones, how should one explain to him where his loved ones have gone? Re: And we think the best way is still: don't tell him the real situation for the time being, just say that they have gone to a faraway place on business, or are studying and working abroad or something like that. When the child understands, has a certain ability to bear the time, and then to tell the truth, the child will also understand the relatives of the practice, will not be angry because they did not know the truth earlier. Is it possible that such words also hinder the integrity!
;