I can answer this question. Others don’t know, but my father knows better. Let me first talk about my father’s situation. My father was born in 1946 and has been dead for eleven years now. My father is a practitioner of traditional martial arts. Where did he learn it? He learned it from an officer of the Kuomintang (who returned to the countryside after the collapse of the Kuomintang). There was no tuition fee at that time, so my father built houses for others. The master gave leaf cigarettes (Sichuan dialect) to his master every day (my father did not smoke). His master first taught horse steps. After he had mastered this movement, he taught other movements. How did he practice at that time? My father was around four o'clock every morning. I just got up and counted while doing the horse stance. I counted more every day, and finally I practiced squatting for an hour and a half. Then do lunges and squats. Anyway, after each movement taught by the master has been practiced, the master said that it is time to practice the next movement, and then the next movement is practiced. The master and my house are not close, it takes about half an hour to walk, and the master does not come to supervise. conscious. After practicing these basic movements for three years, the master taught me the routine. After practicing like this for another three years, the master said he was barely ready to become a master.
Later, when I became wiser, I watched him perform routines. It seemed that the punches were not very fast, a bit like Tai Chi, and a bit like Bajiquan. Later, in actual practice, according to my father's words, the effect was very good. For example, in the past, there was a shortage of fertilizers. Large-scale production collectives had to go to the city to pick up manure and come back to fertilize the crops. The production team sent a few strong laborers to go (a long way). In contrast to what happened with other towns (formerly called communes) In a conflict, the other side has more people and we have fewer people. Many of the opponents wanted to bully my father and they went together, but in the end, except for my father, they were one-on-one. My father fought seven or eight people easily, but the opponent's arm was broken by a punch from my father. Basically, these people can't get close to my father.
Now back to the topic, the basics of practicing martial arts are not good at all. I think that the master has taught a few routines and punched sandbags for a few years, which is enough to practice martial arts. In the past, when practicing martial arts, I started beating with sandbags. After practicing for a period of time, I changed to beating with pebbles (wash with medicinal water before and after practice). It is better to beat the pebbles until they are powdery. Palm training involves inserting thin mud back and forth with both palms until the mud becomes dry and hard. Use mung beans, cooked with steel. If you don't practice for more than three years, let alone martial arts.
Modern Sanda mainly has the following characteristics. First, it is powerful, which can overwhelm hundreds of techniques. Any technique is in vain in the face of absolute power. Second, the movements are simple and more direct, and the punches reach the flesh. Beating the opponent down is the last word. The most commonly used in Sanda are Wangbaquan (swinging fist) and straight fist, as well as direct kicks, side kicks, and side kicks.
To sum up, it is not that Chuan Wu is not good, but that those who practice Chuan Wu have not practiced Chuan Wu well and have not experienced actual combat. Practicing Sanda is simple and straightforward.
I’m not sure, please give me some advice
Watch the training during the competition
The intensity of Chuanwu training is too low and the intensity is far from enough.
My sister and I both practiced martial arts, and then the coach of Shichahai Sports School took a liking to my sister. Recruited to practice Sanda. My sister also likes it.
The first basic training is to stretch the muscles and press the legs. My sister started doing horizontal crosses, vertical crosses, and kicks within a month. Compared with continuing to practice martial arts, it seems standard.
Moreover, Sanda has physical running training, hip opening, cadence, and stride length all have special track and field coaches. My sister's basic skills such as kicking and kicking are different after one month. And the running posture is different. At first glance, it looks like he has been specially trained.
I went to a sports school to see them. They performed various decompositions of straight hooks, swings, punches, forward kicks, low whips and high-tech decompositions. Boxing, kicking the punching bag. The sound of kicking the sandbags was heard. Our senior martial arts masters practiced martial arts very well. Height 17cm, weight 75kg. It's impossible to achieve that solid feeling.
Let’s talk about Sanda throwing techniques. After half a year of training, my sister is already a 60kg sandbag player in the 52kg level. I fell down hundreds of times a day. I weigh 70kg. My sister tried to compete with me in the wrestling gym. As soon as I joined hands, I flew away without knowing what was going on. I fell to the ground with no chance of fighting.
My senior brother is 177 and he has achieved first and second place in Beijing in Chuanburi. He was thrown down as soon as he touched hands.
First of all, if nothing else is said, Chuan Wu is far inferior to Sanda in terms of training formality, training time, strength, speed and density. No training, no competition. You can't touch Chuanwu at all, even amateur Sanda. If you don't blink, you won't be able to pass on the martial arts, let alone the speed of your punches and kicks.
No speed at all. The fists and legs can't touch each other at all, so there is no prerequisite for exerting one's strength.
Later, my family considered that Sanda could be a hobby, but I still had to take the exam. My sister dropped out of sports school.
There is a Kung Fu called kicking in the north. The TV station specially interviewed it. An aunt in her thirties could break three blue bricks stacked diagonally against the corner with one kick. A 15-year-old girl who has been studying for three years can kick a pine tree as thick as a rice bowl.
There are also corresponding routines for kicking, and there is also a story about kicking. In the early years of reform and opening up, the son of the successor of kicking had a quarrel with a few gangsters on the street, and started to kick. The descendant's son used his kick to break the tibias above the ankles of the two gangsters as soon as he started. This resulted in several years of imprisonment. For this reason, there is a rule for kicking people to recruit disciples. Unless it is absolutely necessary, kicking cannot be used.
Who knows if traditional martial arts can be fought? A kicking girl who can break two bricks with one kick and a Sanda practitioner who has been practicing for several months will fight randomly for two minutes to see if the girl falls down or the Sanda practitioner. An athlete loses a leg?
I am very happy to answer such a question. I can tell the Chinese people clearly. I am a member of traditional martial arts. This is a photo of me from more than ten years ago. The combat power of any martial arts school in the world is at the same level. If you fight, you will win or lose. Then the industry must pay attention to a talent. Not everyone can fight if they practice martial arts! The same goes for reading, when Chinese people talk about people. You have to pat your chest and ask your conscience. According to this thinking logic. Can you become a scientist by reading a book? Is this realistic? Is this a composite scientific concept? In reality, how many people who study have not become scientists? It can be said to be the majority! While saying this, are you a scientist? Could it be that you never went to school? I am just a rough guy, a master who has not finished elementary school. The registered permanent residence is Ruichang City, Jiujiang City, Jiangxi Province. My father is a famous local martial arts master. (Nickname: Datang Tianjia Stove) If you don’t believe it, you can go to the local area and ask around! During the collective era, my father was hit by a boulder and injured his lumbar vertebrae during the national water conservancy project overhaul. From a scientific perspective. My father should have been paralyzed in bed for life. But my father never gave up on himself. I relied on my knowledge of traditional Chinese medicine to prescribe and drink medicine for my injuries, combining it with traditional qigong. I insisted on practicing the internal qigong of traditional martial arts every day. Heal for yourself. Miraculously stood up from the bed. Through years of inner Qi conditioning. He can actually do heavy farm work. This is the benefit of Chuanwu! If you don't believe it, you can go to Ruichang, Jiangxi to find out the truth. What I say is true! (My father’s reputation in the local area is not comparable to that of ordinary people! Remember, the nickname is Datang Tianjia Stove)
What I want to tell you here today is. Always deal with problems calmly. When talking about something, you must first understand the facts yourself before making a conclusion! Instead of sitting at home and talking about things based on your own imagination! If what I said is true, I am willing to accept the challenge of boxing and kickboxing for just a few months! I currently live in Anyuan District, Pingxiang City, Jiangxi Province. Let the Chinese people see that Chuanwu is not as bad as you think!
We must speak with conscience. Chuanwu under the same training method is at the same level as all current martial arts. No one is higher or lower. Fighting relies on strength, and people of the same age are all at about the same level. You can't tell anything apart during a fight, and you complain that this doesn't work and that doesn't work. That's completely unreasonable.
Of course, I also know why the Chinese hate Chuanwu so much. It's all because of those so-called martial arts masters. Collect money from everywhere and recruit disciples. Many martial arts enthusiasts have been deceived! I also resent these nasty people for the nasty things they have done. What I want to say next is that selecting a martial arts master is the first factor in the world. If you talk about money when you get in, then they can only be a scam. Whether you can cheat money into your hands or not is a matter of learning. In the current situation, Chuanwu's reputation and status have sounded the death knell. I hope the masters in Chuanwu will take this as a warning. It’s time to change the style of teaching martial arts. If you really want to receive money, can you wait until the person who wants to learn martial arts is successful and then pay according to their wishes? I also hope that the Chinese people can make Chuanwu stronger and bigger! Without losing the essence of Chinese martial arts!
Answer, first, there is no practical awareness. Second, there is no rich practical experience. Without a sense of actual combat, it means that people who practice kung fu are dancing, everything is empty, and they are completing a physical labor. If you really want to use it in actual combat and defeat the opponent, no one will think that someone is practicing it. It may seem like empty gestures, but in fact, the punches are effective.
You can do most of them when you first start practicing. Once you become proficient in boxing, you will become more casual. Assume that you never know how to do it, and you are a newbie, and all his moves will work. How to cover, how to defend, how to attack, and where is your opponent standing? Where is the punch going? Where do your feet step? If the first move is not completed, how can the third move lead to failure? Unless you don't use your brain, it's at the level of half a bottle of water at most. You don't know two things about a punch. One is that the opponent doesn't know, and the other is that you don't know either. As soon as the opponent moves, you will take action subconsciously. There is no practical behavior. Once mastered in boxing, it is mainly used in actual combat, that is, using the shortest distance, fastest speed, and maximum strength to hit the weakest point of the opponent's defense at lightning speed. It must be completed through two-person sparring, effectively mastering the best position, and using your best techniques to defeat the opponent instantly! With practical experience, that is, if you get beaten a lot, you will naturally become defensive. When the opponent hits you, unconsciously, your hands and feet fall on the opponent. Using the opponent's strength to hit the opponent is like lifting a thousand pounds. Open your eyes wide and stare into his eyes. If he moves, you will hate the killer and he will not be able to escape even if he has wings.
Wrong practice.
What is Chuanwu? Is it a routine or a move? None. The essence of Chuanwu is Kung Fu, which is very scientific and highly efficient. It has gone through thousands of years of exploration, accumulation and perfection. Through Kung Fu training, the potential of the human body can be maximized and used to achieve coordination, integration, and unity of the whole body. This Kung Fu is very different from the currently popular Chuan Wu Kung Fu.
The current Chuanwu is very particular about routines and moves. It seems that the more complex the routines, the better, the weirder the moves, the better, and the more you know, the better. In fact, this is a misunderstanding of Chuanwu. For grappling and wrestling, routines and moves are a summary of commonly used techniques. They have a certain effect after being practiced proficiently. In terms of fighting, moves basically have no effect. In fact, when applying, it is all about taking advantage of the situation and strength. There are no certain rules, and it cannot be applied mechanically.
In addition to routines and moves, the current basic skills of Chuanwu are all discrete. One basic skill mainly focuses on practicing one or several functions, while the basic skills of true Chuanwu are concise, concise, and practiced all at once. , it moves at once, so it is very efficient and practical.
The basic skills of Chuan Wu are practiced from the fundamentals, or in other words, they grasp the essence of things rather than their appearance. Once practiced, they will naturally achieve the effect of outlining the main points. So there is no problem of not being able to use it after practicing for several years.
The above is my own experience and is for reference only.
In recent years, there has been a wave of traditional black in China, including black martial arts, black traditional Chinese medicine, black drama, black traditional celebrities, black five thousand years of civilization history, etc. To put it bluntly, they are not confident. The manifestation of historical nihilism is obvious, which started with the pace of China's modernization. From the beginning, the invasion by foreign powers in the late Qing Dynasty, the spread of Western learning to the east, the trend of studying abroad in the Republic of China, the defeat of the Anti-Japanese War, and the differences in the economic and social development levels between China and foreign countries after the founding of the People's Republic of China. With the new wave of studying abroad after the reform, various traditional civilized fields have been gradually invaded or replaced by Western or modern scientific civilization. In the eyes of some people, traditional things have become increasingly worthless in the face of modern scientific civilization. The things of traditional civilization are despised by believers of modern Scientology because they were produced in traditional societies that lagged behind the times, and because they failed to improve with modernization and play their due functions, they have more or less hindered people. Understand them correctly and reasonably. Some people living in modern times have stood at the forefront of the development of the times and have seen the power and role of new science. They have not seriously examined traditional things and have not received scientific thinking training. The loss of traditional civilizations leads to questioning them, denying them, and some people may even question the low IQ of the ancients. This is undoubtedly the result of not understanding history, not understanding thinking, not understanding dialectics, not understanding society, and even not understanding true science. Muscular person. Asking questions in general, answering in general, criticizing in general, affirming or denying in general, thinking is too one-dimensional and difficult to adapt to the real society.
Chuanwu is questioned today, mainly because it is not as effective as we imagined. Not only does it fail to show victory in regular arenas, it also does not show its traditional advantages in private fights. Come on, the result is obvious. If you can't beat it, you can't beat it. There's nothing to argue with. Especially compared with modern Sanda, it's made too many jokes, causing the martial arts practitioners to be collectively humiliated and the Sanda practitioners to be collectively proud. It seems like Chuanwu is not worth showing off for a penny, but you can get into the palace with a few months of sparring and have the same real skills. In fact, we have to look at it dialectically, and the specific analysis of specific issues must be combined with the times and facts.
"Why can't some people who have practiced traditional martial arts for more than ten years not be able to defeat those who have practiced Sanda for a few months?" There are various opinions on the Internet, including those who have not practiced martial arts, martial arts enthusiasts, martial artists, Sanda fighters and others have basically stated the reasons why Chuan Wu cannot fight.
First, its functions and properties have changed. In ancient times, martial arts were mostly used for food and life-saving functions. "Learn martial arts well and sell them to the emperor's family." Ancient people learned martial arts, not just simple hand and foot skills, but also weapon skills. The so-called eighteen kinds Martial arts were basically all about weapon kung fu. At that time, it was mainly about whether you could fight. If you couldn't fight, no one would learn it. If no one learned it, the martial arts school would decline or even disappear. Therefore, you should learn the kung fu to be able to fight as a skill when going out to protect yourself. As a bodyguard to look after homes and homes, to open a bodyguard bureau to escort property, to go to the battlefield to gain military honors, etc., each one relies on martial arts to save one's life. If martial arts is not good, you will die first, your own wealth and life, other people's property, the master's life, and battlefield military exploits. No need to talk about it. Therefore, the martial arts that can be passed down due to historical accumulation and waves must still have some gold content, but times have changed. Today, it is no better than in the past. The era of practicing martial arts as a way to save life has passed. Now it is mainly used for fitness, performance, and opening boxing. After the founding of the People's Republic of China, the country also consciously eliminated martial arts fighting skills for the sake of social stability. The most important life-saving function is no longer available, so who can care about it? Even if you know how to fight for a few times, if you win accidentally you will go to jail or lose a lot of money. Who dares to fight? After martial arts loses its due life-saving function, it is good that everyone gradually loses their attention. Got it.
The second is insufficient skill. The so-called sayings such as "Practice boxing without practicing martial arts will lead to nothing" and "One force can defeat ten skills" are all the basics of martial arts handed down from traditional martial arts. As long as the foundation is laid, the skills are acquired, and the moves are more or less good, basically it is impossible to start. Will suffer a loss. Now when we talk about traditional martial arts, we only look at the number of gestures on the hands and feet, whether they are familiar or not, and whether they look good or not. They are called masters and dare to accept disciples. Such people probably do not have any actual basic skills. Needless to say, when it comes to Sanda Even if you meet a young and strong young man, you can't beat him. In order to eat and save life, the ancients worked hard every day. Even if there were no modern training equipment, sandbags, stone locks, iron bars, broadswords, and footwork were all trained every day. For several years in a row, they would not fail. Kung Fu is amazing, if you have great strength, if you practice martial arts well and show your skills well, it will be easy to win.
The third is lack of awareness, skills and training. Having skills, learning several sets of martial arts, and becoming familiar with them is not enough. You also need to constantly practice on the field, compete in martial arts, visit, and even fight with real swords and guns. No matter how good you are at practicing by yourself, When it comes to actual application, it won't show much real things, because there are always many variables in real fighting, and it will not be based on your own routines. Even if the fighting routines of the same martial arts are similar, they will not be exactly the same, let alone other schools. In addition, when encountering the use of weapons to fight, a careless move can result in trauma, bleeding, or broken muscles, disability, and life loss. Therefore, we will do everything we can to use caution to defeat the enemy and win. In actual combat, we must combine the awareness of offense and defense, and the awareness of virtuality and reality. If you show your strength and skills in daily training and experience many actual combat situations, you will definitely be able to fight.
Today's Sanda fighters spend every day in the boxing gym, receive scientific training, scientifically combine nutrition, high-tech equipment, and frequent Sanda competitions. They have deep basic skills, proficient skills, awareness, and more actual combat. Naturally, I can display my due martial arts skills according to the opponent's moves. In ancient times, Sanda was called Sanshou. As the saying goes, when the soldiers come, I will block the water and cover it with the earth. I will take whatever moves come. That is, the more you practice, the more proficient you will be. You will be able to fight. , no matter who the opponent is, he can remain invincible.
Therefore, today’s Chuan Wu cannot practice boxing at high intensity every day; second, it has not kept up with scientific training; third, there is no scientific nutrition; fourth, there is no modern high-tech training equipment; fifth, there is no actual combat situation, which will lead to the destruction of martial arts over time. , most of them are reduced to pure fitness and performance, and it is too normal to be inferior to modern Sanda. If you want to say whether there is real Kung Fu in Chuan Wu, then there definitely is. Many Chuan Wu Kung Fu moves are hidden. There must be some among the special forces and special police. They sometimes use them to save their lives when they go on missions. How can they complete their missions without real Kung Fu? , special warriors train every day, use high-tech equipment, nutritional science, and practice a lot of actual combat. They have whatever they want, and they will definitely be able to produce real skills. Even if you can't beat a professional boxer with bare hands, with weapons, it's basically difficult for a professional boxer to survive.
The most important thing is that the training methods are different. In Chuanwu, the main focus is on routines and Sanda as a supplement. That is, the master usually teaches routines and practices them all day long. He only teaches them sometimes. Sanshou (technical attack) is just a lesson. I know roughly that most martial arts are practiced in this way. The emergence of fighting itself is to think about how to defeat the opponent, so the beginning of training is in this direction. , just a few hours of punching sandbags and various physical training every day, the amount of exercise is far more than that of Chuanwu practitioners. I have a friend who practices Sanda. According to him, every time he hits sandbags, when he is too tired to bear it, When he wanted to lower his hands, the coach stood behind the sandbag and kicked him. He instinctively waved his hands and continued to hit the sandbag... After practicing this for several months, his impact alone was no longer something that ordinary people could withstand. of. In addition, actual combat and sparring are commonplace. Many martial arts techniques seem easy to understand when listening to the master's instructions. However, only after a long period of sparring or actual combat can we truly understand and remember them deeply. Only then can we truly understand the meaning of the moves taught by the master.
A simple example: the basic skill of Tongjiquan "speed down" is similar to a half squat. I can probably do 80-100 reps in a row, but the passing mark is 300 reps. There are masters who can do more than 3,000 reps in a row with a weight of 20 kilograms! The result is: The lower limbs are powerful and explosive, advancing and retreating as fast and fast as an ape, and the shape is like a ghost! But I'm just weak and vulnerable! That's it for competitive sports: strength, speed and explosiveness are the foundation, and the rest are all methods and skills!
Why can’t a person who has practiced traditional martial arts for more than ten years fail to beat someone who has practiced Sanda for a few months? The transformation of my country's traditional martial arts into "dance" or even a tool to defraud money is not a topic that is new today, it has even existed since ancient times. During the Ming Dynasty, Yu Dayou, a famous anti-Japanese general, suffered from the fact that his troops were not as good as Japanese samurai in fighting. He even went to Wudang Mountain and Shaolin Temple to look for martial arts masters. It turns out that Wudang Mountain martial arts is just a "game", and the famous Shaolin martial arts is just "dance", with fancy fists and embroidered legs, with no actual combat value. In turn, he taught his martial arts to Shaolin monks. Only then did the so-called Shaolin martial arts have some practical value.
In the past two years, some folk Sanda masters have frequently challenged those famous "martial arts masters". What is unexpected is that these "martial arts masters" were defeated one after another, and there was even a shocking scene where they were beaten to the ground and unable to get up just four seconds after the fight started. It was so lively for a while, and the traditional martial arts community was full of jokes, which shocked people. In the end, they had to use public power to issue a ban on private martial arts competitions and "kick-in", so as to protect the face of "martial arts masters". But this just proves how liar these “gurus” are, and how deep the water is.
"Kicking the gym" is a tradition of Chinese martial arts. If you dare to open a martial arts gym, you must not be afraid of someone kicking the gym. Otherwise, what kind of morality will there be? Blindly protecting shortcomings will not only attract people's attention, but will not be beneficial to the promotion of true traditional martial arts.