Yunnan Zhaotong strictest dog walking order triggered heated debate

According to Zhejiang Online 2018 report, Hangzhou City, in November 15, 2018 to the end of December, before the start of the citywide "civilized dog" centralized remedial action, according to the provisions of the According to the regulations, the time for walking dogs in Hangzhou city is from 7:00 pm to 7:00 am every day. Walking the dog must be fastened with a dog chain, and led by an adult; serious cases (such as unleashed, resulting in injuries, etc.) will be confiscated dogs, revocation of the "dog permit". Unlicensed dog will be fined up to 5,000 yuan.

According to a previous report by the Beijing Youth Daily, on October 29, 2018, Wenshan City, Yunnan Province, issued a "dog-keeping restrictions": dog owners can only go out to walk their dogs before 7:00 a.m. and after 10:00 p.m.; the dog's leash can't be more than 1 meter long and can only be pulled by an adult; parks, shopping malls, sports facilities, and other public**** places are closed to dogs at all times. Parks, shopping centers, sports facilities and other public ****ing places say "no" to dogs at all times.

November 1, 2019, "Taiyuan City dog management regulations" will be officially implemented. "Dogs must be licensed, walk the dog must lead the rope, rope length of no more than 1.2 meters, children can not walk the dog alone, take the dog on the elevator to avoid the peak ......" "Regulations" provides for the implementation of a registration system for raising dogs in key management areas. According to the provisions of the regulations, dog owners once the violation, depending on the severity of the situation, will face a fine of 50 yuan -2000 yuan, and even confiscate the dog.

On November 26 this year, Zhengzhou Zhengshang Yuyuan 5 homeowners reflected that their neighborhood recently came out of the "dog ban", the district prohibited the raising of dogs, if someone is found to have a dog, will be "punished", and there will be a community worker Door to door, requiring the dog to dispose of itself. If the tenant has a dog, the landlord will require that the dog either be sent away or moved.

Some people support, some people question

Yunnan Zhaotong issued the most stringent dog restriction in history, causing netizens to discuss. Some netizens expressed support and hope that the national promotion, but there are also many people questioned whether the law enforcement is excessive?

--Civilization can be achieved by dog walking, holding the leash, picking up dog feces, but can not be limited, the earth belongs to every life

--I support the national promotion, and should be more stringent, the public **** area can not exist to walk the dog! line

-- support the national promotion of fantastic, to the Yunnan Zhaotong municipal government point a praise, did a good thing

December 3, Yunnan Zhaotong City, Zhaoyang District City Management Comprehensive Law Enforcement Bureau issued a "Zhaoyang District City Management Comprehensive Law Enforcement Bureau of the standardization of the center of the city Dog management notice", as follows:

With the creation of a national civilized city, national health city work continues to promote, Zhaotong city center city order, environmental health, civilized travel improved significantly, but there are still some people walking dogs illegally, unleashed dog, dog feces, damage to green space, nuisance, stray dogs, large potent dogs hurt people, etc., to the urban image and the The general public has caused an adverse impact on the city's image and the general public. In order to further clean and beautify the cityscape, improve the living environment, maintain public **** order, promote social harmony, and further regulate the city's uncivilized dog behavior, to protect the physical and mental health of the public and the safety of life, is now the relevant matters are notified as follows:

a. Prohibit the dog into the public **** area

The dog owner should be in his single-family residence or fixed breeding It is prohibited to keep dogs in public **** areas such as institutions and health care, educational institutions, enterprises and institutions.

00:00 a.m. - 6:00 a.m. out of the dog must be on a leash, the dog wearing a muzzle, dog owners to clean up dog feces in a timely manner; 6:00 a.m. - 00:00 a.m. within the following public **** area is prohibited to any dog:

1, the main and secondary roads in central urban areas, backstreets and alleyways;

2, organizations, groups, enterprises, institutions, office areas, production areas;

3, hospital treatment areas, school teaching areas, student dormitory areas, kindergartens and other children and youth activities;

4, shopping malls, hotels, restaurants;

5, scenic spots, parks, squares, urban public **** green space and other public **** place;

5, scenic spots, parks, squares, urban public **** green space and so on. places;

6, theaters, museums, libraries, exhibition halls, stadiums (halls), dance halls, amusement parks and other public cultural and entertainment venues;

7, airports, stations and other public **** passenger transport places and cabs, buses, online carriers and other public **** passenger transport carriers;

8, places of religious activities;

9, and other places with a ban on signs of the premises.

Second, to carry out the stray dog centralized cleanup from now on, the central city is not leashed, not in the specified time into the public **** area, feces no one cleaned up the dog, are regarded as a stray dog for disposal. Stray dogs will be urban management and law enforcement departments, street offices, communities and other departments for centralized shelter disposal. Please civilize the general public to raise dogs, civilized sneaking dogs. Third, this notice from the date of publication of the notice.

Hereby notice.

Recently, Zhaotong City, Yunnan Province, Zhaoyang District Urban Management Bureau issued a "standardization of dog management in the central city . Circular" triggered the attention of netizens, the "notice" to restrict the dog in the "6:00 am - 00:00 am within the prohibited dogs into" including "the center of the city's main and secondary roads, backstreets and alleys," including the public **** area. It also requires dogs to be muzzled.

The matter quickly became a hot topic on the Internet. Some netizens suggested that the national implementation, but there are also netizens questioned whether the law enforcement is excessive?

On the morning of December 5, Zhaoyang District Urban Management and Comprehensive Law Enforcement Bureau, a duty officer told the Xiaoxiang Morning News reporter, the "Notice" by the higher departments of the leadership of the instructions issued by the public have different views can be put forward, and its feedback to the leadership of the public will be given a reply. At the same time, the staff explained that the dog wearing a mask refers to wear anti-bite masks, not anti-epidemic masks.

In this regard, Shanghai Dabang Law Firm attorney Ding Jinkun that the city management as law enforcement shall be administered in accordance with the law, can not expand or reduce the scope of law enforcement, the lack of legal basis of the "Notice" is invalid, in addition to the language of the legislation to be rigorous, "such as what is the 'backstreets and alleys', there must be defined! Only then there is operability."

Zhaoyang District Urban Management Bureau "dog walking order": 12:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m. to walk the dog must be bolted and muzzled

December 3, Zhaoyang District Urban Management and Comprehensive Law Enforcement Bureau issued the "standardization of dog management in the central city of the notice" (hereinafter referred to as "notice"), for the "There are still some people walking dogs in violation of the law, not leashed slipped dog, dog poop, damage to green space, nuisance, stray dogs, large potent dog injury incidents and other issues", to further regulate the urban area of the uncivilized dog breeding behavior notice.

"Notice" shows that dogs are prohibited from entering the public **** area, requiring "00:00 am - 6:00 am out of the slipper dog must be bolted to the rope, the dog wearing a muzzle, the dog breeder to clean up the dog feces in a timely manner", in addition to the requirements of "6:00 am - 00:00 am within the dog, the dog must be bolted to the rope, the dog wearing a muzzle, the dog breeder timely clean up dog excrement".

△ Zhaoyang District Urban Management Bureau issued a "notice on the standardization of dog management in the central city"

Subsequently, some netizens believe that the local release of the "notice" is responsible for the public helplessness, hope that "the national implementation"; but some netizens questioned: this is equivalent to the provisions of the dog breeders! The first time I've ever seen a dog in a car, it was in the middle of the night, and it was in the middle of the night.

The Dashboard reporter noted that on December 4, a netizen left a message for the local government on the People's Daily's message board, saying, "Dog owners can only walk their dogs from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m., and dogs are prohibited from going out at any other time of the day, including the streets and alleys. This provision is neither civilized nor reasonable, not even a little humane. Civilized dog ownership should be going out on a leash, picking up dog poop and feces, and if the dog is not walked in a civilized manner, penalties and education may be imposed. Instead of a broad-brush, prohibit the dog to go out ...... at night from twelve to six o'clock, whether the law enforcement is excessive."

△ netizens questioned whether the local law enforcement is excessive

Local dog management methods: no restriction on the specific time to walk the dog

The official website of the Zhaotong Municipal People's Government shows that, since June 1, 2018 came into force, "Zhaotong City City City Management Ordinance" (hereinafter referred to as the "Regulations"), Article 21, paragraph 2, provides that it is prohibited to "Letting dogs and pets excrete feces on urban roads and other public **** sites", if violated then the comprehensive administrative law enforcement department of urban management will give criticism and education, and order to correct; if you refuse to correct, you will be fined more than 10 yuan and less than 50 yuan.

At the same time, the "Regulations" Article 30 provides that: keeping pets shall not affect the lives of others, endangering the safety of others, large dogs, potent dogs should be kept in captivity or tethered, shall not be released, carrying other pets out of the house, should be tied; if a violation of the integrated administrative law enforcement departments of urban management ordered to correct, impose a fine of more than $ 50 to less than $ 200.

In addition, since December 1, 2008 will come into force, "Zhaotong City, dog management (for trial implementation)" (hereinafter referred to as "measures"), Article IV, paragraph 4, the urban management and administration of the department's responsibility for investigating and dealing with the destruction of the city's environmental sanitation due to dog breeding.

Article 12 of the Measures stipulates that it is prohibited to bring dogs into the following places: (a) offices and production areas of institutions, organizations, enterprises and institutions; (b) hospital treatment areas, school teaching areas, student dormitories, kindergartens, and other places where children and teenagers are active; (c) shopping malls, hotels, and food establishments; (d) scenic spots, urban parks, urban public **** green space and other public * * * places; (E) theaters, museums, libraries, exhibition halls, stadiums (museums), dance halls, playgrounds, stations and other public cultural and entertainment venues; (F) other places with a ban on signs. Managers may refuse to bring dogs into the above places. If the violation of the public security organs in accordance with the provisions of the "Chinese People's Republic of China *** and the State Administration of Public Security Punishment Law" to be punished; constitutes a crime, according to the law, be investigated for criminal responsibility.

△ "Zhaotong City dog management approach (for trial implementation)" Article 12 provides for the prohibition of dogs into the place

The reporter noted that the aforementioned "Notice" to limit the dog into the public **** place, "the central city main and secondary roads, back streets and alleys," is not in the local provisions of the restrictive In addition, there is no detailed local restrictions on dog owners to walk their dogs.

City Council response: refers to the "anti-bite masks", issued by the higher authorities departmental instructions, there are different opinions can be raised

December 5 morning, Zhaoyang District Urban Management and Comprehensive Law Enforcement Bureau, a duty officer told the Xiaoxiang Morning News reporter, the "Notice" by the higher authorities departmental leadership instructions issued by the public have different opinions can be raised, it to the higher authorities departmental instructions, the public have different opinions can be raised, it to the higher authorities departmental instructions, the public have different opinions can be raised. Opinions can be put forward, its feedback to the higher leadership will give the public reply.

Subsequently, Zhaoyang District Urban Management Bureau Phoenix Law Enforcement Brigade and Longquan Law Enforcement Brigade staff told reporters that the "Notice" stipulates that "dogs wear muzzles", is required to wear a "bite-proof muzzle" rather than an epidemic-proof muzzle, in addition to the specific law enforcement recommendations Citizens can "put the garbage bag and pet leash ready, civilized dog".

"(Enforcement) in this regard is biased humane, because we also have colleagues to raise dogs, they also said is not able to walk the dog, the opinion is relatively large." A law enforcement officer told reporters.

Can the local urban management bureau stipulate the time for dog owners to walk their dogs? Shanghai Dabang Law Firm lawyer Ding Jinkun believes that the city management as law enforcement shall be administered according to law, can not expand or reduce the scope of law enforcement, the lack of legal basis for the "Notice" is invalid. "The local provisions, can seek advice to amend the implementation, rather than let the city management to expand their own provisions to implement. Secondly, the legislative language should be rigorous, such as what is 'backstreets and alleys', there must be a definition in order to be operable."