Table of Contents
Purpose
Aims
Benefits
Audit Procedures I. Planning and Organization Stage
II. Pre-Assessment Stage
III. Evaluation Stage
IV. Stage
VII. Continuous Cleaner Production Stage
Interim Measures for Cleaner Production Audit Purpose
Aims
Benefits
Audit Procedures I. Planning and Organizing Stage
II. Pre-Assessment Stage
III, Feasibility Analysis Stage
VI. Program Implementation Stage
VII. Continuous Clean Production Stage
Interim Measures for Cleaner Production Audit
Expand Edit Purpose
Energy Saving, Reducing Consumption, Emission Reduction, and Efficiency Increase Elimination (or reduction) of hazardous substances on the products, reduction of consumption of raw materials and energy in the process of production, and lowering of production costs in order to reduce the harm to human health environment.
Edit Paragraph Purpose
In order to promote the sustainable development of the dyeing and finishing industry and comprehensively consider the mutual coordination of the economy and the environment, so as to promote the unity of economic and environmental benefits.
Edit paragraph benefits
For the enterprise, it can really reduce the cost, reduce the enterprise's raw material consumption and energy consumption, and improve the efficiency of material and energy use. For the country, it really contains the central task of the country's energy saving and emission reduction, and it is an important initiative of China's commitment to the world to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. For the local government, it is an important method and way to fulfill the national task of energy saving and emission reduction.
Edit this section of the audit process
I. Planning and organization stage
Focus on obtaining the support and participation of senior corporate leadership, the formation of a cleaner production audit team, the development of the audit work plan and the promotion of cleaner production ideas. A leadership support 1, preach the benefits: economic benefits, environmental benefits, intangible assets, technological progress 2, clarification of inputs: management personnel, technicians and operational workers necessary time investment; monitoring equipment and monitoring costs of the necessary inputs; preparation of the audit report costs, as well as the possible cost of hiring external experts. Second set up an audit team 1, the establishment of cleaner production audit leading group: head of the company's general manager, deputy head of the deputy general manager in charge of as members of the technology, technology, environmental protection, management, finance, production and other departments and production workshops responsible for the composition. The main responsibilities are to determine the focus of the current cleaner production audit; set up and check the work of the audit team; make the necessary decisions on the actual work of cleaner production; and make a ruling on the required costs. 2、Establishment of clean production audit working group: the leader is the deputy general manager in charge, the deputy leader is the person in charge of the management department, technology department and production department, and the members are composed of the management, technology, environmental protection, technology, finance, procurement and the relevant personnel of the production workshop. The main responsibility is to develop the audit plan according to the audit priorities determined by the leading group, and organize the relevant departments to work according to the plan. Three to develop a work plan After the establishment of the audit team, we should prepare a timely audit work schedule, including the content of each stage of the work, the completion time, the responsible department and person in charge, the assessment of the department and the personnel, the output and so on. Four to carry out publicity and education 1, Purpose: so that all employees of the enterprise to understand the concept of cleaner production and the implementation of the significance and role of cleaner production, clarification of fuzzy understanding, to overcome the possible barriers to all kinds of ideas, consciously participate in cleaner production work. 2、Publicity and education is divided into three levels, namely, factory level, department level and group level publicity and training. In the development of cleaner production initial factory-level training is the main, generally through a large class in the form of training courses and so on. Departmental level training is generally carried out after the cleaner production audit is launched, and the department will formulate a publicity plan according to the overall promotion plan of the enterprise and implement it according to the work carried out. Workgroup-level publicity and training is mainly concentrated in the production team. 3, the way of publicity: the use of various regular meetings of the enterprise, radio, newspapers, television video, issued documents, organizational learning, training courses, the issuance of briefings, the mass of essays, rationalization proposals, and other forms of activities to carry out the concept of cleaner production and implementation of the significance of cleaner production and the role of publicity and education activities, to clarify the fuzzy understanding. 4, publicity content: the concept of cleaner production and cleaner production audit; the significance and role of cleaner production; cleaner production audit of the content and requirements; the enterprise to encourage the cleaner production audit of the various measures; the enterprise has been achieved in various sectors of the audit results and specific practices. 5、Operating points: publicity to develop a publicity plan; to regular meetings, team meetings in the form of publicity, there should be meeting records; knowledge of cleaner production, cleaner production audit work progress should be sent in the form of briefings to the relevant leaders, departments, workshops and so on.
Two, pre-assessment stage
Pre-assessment, is the whole process of production, the current situation of the enterprise research and investigation, to find out the current state of pollution and pollution focus and through qualitative comparisons or quantitative analysis, to determine the focus of the audit. The focus of the work is to evaluate the enterprise's pollution and sewage situation, to determine the audit focus, and set clean production goals for the audit focus. An organization of the status quo research (enterprise profile, environmental conditions, production conditions, management conditions, etc.). This step by the production, environmental protection, management and other departments to collect relevant information, the status quo research. Two on-site inspection (production process, pollution, energy consumption of key links, parts) this step by the production, environmental protection, management and other departments to organize relevant personnel to carry out on-site inspections, found in the production of the problem. Three evaluation of the production and discharge of sewage situation (production and discharge of sewage status quo analysis, analogical evaluation). This step by the environmental protection, technology and other departments of the enterprise's production and pollution causes preliminary analysis and evaluation. Four to determine the focus of the audit (application of the findings of the current situation, analysis to determine the focus of the audit). This step by the audit leading group based on the information obtained, listed the main issues of the enterprise, from which a number of issues or links as alternative audit focus. 1, the alternative focus of the sector: such as production workshops, sections, operating units, equipment, production lines, pollutants generated by the process. 2, alternative key conditions: serious pollution links or parts; consumption of links or parts; environmental and public pressure links or issues; serious impact or threat to normal production constitutes the production of "bottlenecks" in the parts; in the regional environmental quality improvement plays a key role in the links. General consumption or pollution of heavy links or parts of the cleaner production audit as an alternative focus, generally 3-5. 3, the method of determining the audit focus: according to the alternative focus of waste emissions, toxicity and consumption, etc., comparison, analysis, demonstration, audit team members can be used to vote on the method of selecting the audit focus. Usually the most serious pollution, consumption of the largest parts of the first round of audit focus, while taking into account the capital, technology, business objectives, annual plans and other factors. Five set clean production goals (for the audit focus, set clean production goals) Audit focus on the determination of the audit leading group to develop a clear clean production goals: that is, the audit focus on the implementation of clean production requirements to be achieved. 1, set the type of objectives Immediate objectives: refers to the cleaner production audit to achieve the objectives, including environmental objectives and energy consumption, water consumption, material consumption, economic efficiency and other aspects of the target. Medium- and long-term goals: refers to the level and capacity achieved after continuous clean production, continuous improvement or major technological transformation and equipment renewal. The medium and long-term goals are generally 2-3 years. 2. Principles for setting targets: advanced; operable; in line with national industrial policy and environmental protection requirements; and obvious economic benefits. 3. Factors to be considered: environmental management requirements and industrial policy requirements; enterprise production technology level and equipment capacity; the level of similar-sized manufacturers at home and abroad; the best level of the enterprise's history; the enterprise's financial situation. VI Propose and implement no-low-cost program (implement the principle of implementation while reviewing) No-low-cost program refers to the program that can make the problem solved without or less investment. This step can be led by the management and production departments, with the cooperation of relevant departments, through talks, consultation, site visits, distribution of clean production proposal forms, etc., to widely mobilize employees to propose no-low-cost solutions for their respective jobs, specifically around the following aspects: 1. Raw and auxiliary materials and energy. Common no-low-cost programs are: should not order too many raw materials, especially some will be damaged, easy to fail or difficult to store the raw materials; raw materials into the material, warehousing, discharge measurement management, plug all kinds of loopholes and losses; raw materials into the factory inspection, quality control of supply. 2, the technical process. Common no-low-fee programs are: add the necessary instruments, meters and automatic testing and indicating devices to improve the automation level of the production process; local adjustments to the production process; adjust the auxiliaries, additives and other inputs. 3、Equipment. Common no-low-fee programs are: improve and strengthen the regular inspection and maintenance of equipment to reduce leakage; timely repair and improve the heat and gas pipeline insulation and heat preservation. 4、Process control. Common no-low-fee solutions include: choosing to produce under the optimal dosage ratio; increasing and calibrating testing and measuring instruments; improving process control and online monitoring; and adjusting and optimizing the parameters of the reaction, such as temperature and pressure. 5. Product. Common no-low-cost solutions are: improve packaging and its signs or instructions; strengthen inventory management; packaging materials to facilitate recycling or treatment, disposal. 6, the generation of waste. Common no-low-fee programs are: liquid waste to take precipitation, filtration and collection measures; solid waste to take cleaning, selection and recycling measures; condensation of steam to take measures to recover. 7, management status. Common no-low-fee programs are: clean operations to avoid clutter; reduce material loss and timely collection; strict job responsibility system and operating procedures. 8、Employee quality. Common no-low-fee programs are: to strengthen the staff technology and environmental awareness training; the use of various forms of spiritual and material incentives.
Three, the assessment phase
Establishment of the audit focuses on the balance of materials, waste generation cause analysis. The focus of this phase is to measure the input and output logistics, establish a material balance, analyze the causes of waste generation. A preparation of audit focus information (collect information, preparation of process, equipment flow chart). This step by the production, environmental protection, management and other departments to collect the audit has been determined focus on the relevant information, and strive to complete the information. Two measured input and output materials (measured, summarized data). This step by the production sector in accordance with the requirements put forward by the audit team, the actual measurement of input and output materials, in accordance with the standard collection of data, environmental protection and measurement departments to cooperate. Measurement time and cycle: for cyclical (intermittent) production of enterprises, according to the normal production cycle (i.e., an ingredient from input to product output for a production cycle) for the measurement of each process, and at least three cycles of measurement. For enterprises with continuous production, continuous (shift) monitoring should be 72 hours. Three to establish the material balance (measurement and preparation of material balance diagram). This step consists of the production department compiling material balance diagrams (material balance diagrams, water balance diagrams) in accordance with the measured data. Four analyze the causes of waste generation (for the audit focus on analyzing the causes of waste generation). Audit working group to organize environmental protection, production, technology, process and other departments to analyze the causes of waste generation and propose solutions. Generally analyze the causes of waste generation from the following aspects 1, raw and auxiliary materials and energy (purity, storage and transportation, inputs, over-quota, toxic and hazardous, clean energy, etc.) 2, technology and process (conversion rate, equipment layout, conversion steps, stability, the need to use environmentally hazardous materials, etc.) 3, equipment (breakage, leakage, automation level, configuration between equipment, maintenance, equipment function and process matching, etc.) 4, process Control (measurement, testing and analysis instruments, process parameters, control level) 5, products (storage and transportation of broken, leakage, conversion rate, packaging) 6, waste (waste recycling and reuse, physical and chemical properties and processing, the amount of waste generated per unit of product and the domestic and international advanced level) 7, management (management system and the implementation of the need to meet the needs of cleaner production) 8, employees (the quality of the production and the needs of the lack of incentives) V proposed and implemented No low cost program (for audit focus). By the audit working group proposed program, the production sector specific implementation.
Four, program generation and screening stage
To address the causes of waste generation, put forward the program and screening. The purpose of this phase is to generate, screen and develop programs to provide sufficient medium/high cost cleaner production programs for the next phase of feasibility analysis. I Generate programs (widely mobilize the public to solicit, full participation, quality and quantity). By the audit working group to organize the whole staff to solicit, engineering and technical personnel to participate in the expert group to participate in and guide. 1, the way to collect: hold a workshop workers, managers and plant-related functional departments to participate in a special meeting, wide open, brainstorming; set up a rationalization proposal box, collect units and individual opinions. 2, the basic types of programs: strengthen management; raw and auxiliary materials to change and energy substitution; improve process technology; optimize the production process control; waste recycling and recycling; staff incentives and quality improvement; equipment maintenance and renewal; product updates and improvements. The second classification summarizes the program (all the programs according to the eight aspects of the list of cylinder description and prediction). By the audit working group according to feasible options, temporarily infeasible options, infeasible options for classification and summary. Three screening program (preliminary screening or weighted sum of points sorting screening and summary). By the audit working group to organize environmental protection, technology, technology, production and other departments to screen the program, screening out 3-5 high cost program. Four development programs (engineering analysis, provide more than two programs for research). By the production, technology, process and other departments of the program development, for the next stage for feasibility analysis. V Continue to implement no/low cost options (implement screened feasible no/low cost options) VI Approve and summarize the effects of no/low cost option implementation (summary analysis of milestones) Summarize the implemented no/low cost options (including those implemented in the pre-assessment and assessment phases). The summarized content includes program serial number, name, implementation time, investment, running cost, implementation requirements, possible impact on production status after implementation, economic benefits and environmental effects. VII preparation of cleaner production mid-term audit report (summary analysis of the results of the phase of work)
V. Feasibility analysis stage
Screened medium and high cost program for the study and recommendation. The focus of this stage is, in combination with market research and collection of certain information on the basis of the program's technical, environmental, economic feasibility analysis and comparison, from which to select and recommend the best feasible program. One conducts market investigation (when it involves product restructuring, new products and raw materials generation). Organize personnel to understand market demand, predict market dynamics, consult with experts, process technicians to carry out calculations to determine the program. Second, technical assessment (process route, technical equipment, technical maturity, etc.). The technical department provides new search information, and conducts technical assessment on the advancement, practicability and operability of the program. Environmental assessment (resource consumption, environmental impact and comprehensive utilization of waste, etc.) by the environmental protection, energy conservation and other departments to provide relevant information on the program's waste quantity, recycling, degradability, toxicity, secondary pollution, etc. for environmental assessment. Four economic assessment (cash flow analysis and financial dynamic profitability analysis). The financial department provides profit and loss statements and liability statements, and conducts economic assessment of the program's investment repayment period, net present value, net present value rate, and internal rate of return. Five recommended implementable programs (to determine the best feasible recommended programs). Organize experts and technical personnel in accordance with the technologically advanced and practical, economically rational and beneficial, and protect the environment requirements, the program review, to determine the cleaner production program. The best feasible program refers to the investment program is technologically advanced and applicable, economically rational and beneficial, and can protect the environment of the optimal program.
Sixth, the program implementation stage
Implementation of the program, and analysis and verification of the implementation of the program. The focus of this stage is: summarize the results of the previous stages of the audit has been implemented in the cleaner production program, integrated planning and implementation of the recommended programs. A program to organize the implementation of the program (integrated planning, financing, implementation of the program) Second summary of the results of the implementation of no / low cost program (economic and environmental benefits) Third verification of the results of the implementation of the medium / high cost program (economic and environmental benefits and comprehensive evaluation) Fourth analysis and summary of the implementation of the program on the organization's impact (the implementation of the effectiveness of comparative publicity)
Seven, the stage of sustained cleaner production
Second stage of cleaner production
Developing plans, measures to continue to promote the implementation of the recommended program. p>Development of plans, measures to sustain the implementation and preparation of reports. This phase focuses on: the establishment of the implementation and management of cleaner production work organization, the establishment of management systems to promote the implementation of cleaner production, the development of sustained cleaner production plan and preparation of cleaner production audit report. Establishment and improvement of cleaner production organization (task, attribution and responsibility) Establishment and improvement of cleaner production management system (management, incentives and funding) Formulation of continuous cleaner production plan (work, implementation, research and development, and training) Preparation of a cleaner production audit report (a summary and analysis of the results of the overall work) A cleaner production audit is, first of all, an analysis and assessment of the organization's current and planned production of products and services for the implementation of pollution prevention. The Cleaner Production Audit begins with a pollution prevention analysis and assessment of the organization's current and planned products and services. In the implementation of pollution prevention analysis and assessment process, the development and implementation of programs to reduce the use of energy, resources and raw materials, eliminate or reduce the use of toxic substances in products and production processes, reduce the amount of various types of waste emissions and their toxicity.
Edit Interim Measures for Cleaner Production Audit
The interim measures are different in each place, such as Dongguan City, the city rewarded 300,000 for enterprises through cleaner production audit, Guangdong Province enterprises through cleaner production audit, the province rewarded 50,000, the Hong Kong Productivity Council of Hong Kong-funded enterprises in the Pearl River Delta through the Cleaner Production Audit, a reward of 190,000, and there are also energy-saving and emission reduction projects to support. Detailed policies can be found on the relevant government websites. State Environmental Protection Administration Decree No. 16 In order to comprehensively promote cleaner production, standardize the cleaner production audit behavior, according to the "Chinese People's Republic of China *** and the State Cleaner Production Promotion Law" and the division of responsibilities of the relevant departments of the State Council, the National Development and Reform Commission, the State Environmental Protection Administration formulated and considered and adopted the "Interim Measures for Cleaner Production Audit," is hereby promulgated since October 1, 2004 shall come into force. Director of the National Development and Reform Commission: Ma Kai Director of the State Environmental Protection Administration: Xie Zhenhua August 16, 2004 CHAPTER I GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1 These Measures are formulated in accordance with the Cleaner Production Promotion Law of the People's Republic of China for the promotion of cleaner production and the standardization of cleaner production audits. Article 2 The cleaner production audit referred to in these measures refers to a certain procedure, the production and service process of investigation and diagnosis, to find out the reasons for high energy consumption, high material consumption, pollution, and put forward to reduce the use of toxic and hazardous materials, to reduce energy consumption, material consumption and waste generation program, and then select the technically, economically and environmentally feasible cleaner production program process. Article 3 These Measures shall apply to all units engaged in production and service activities as well as departments engaged in relevant management activities within the territory of the People's Republic of China. Article 4 The National Development and Reform Commission, in conjunction with the State Environmental Protection Administration, shall be responsible for the management of national cleaner production audits. Provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the Central Government, municipalities and Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps development and reform (economy and trade) administrative departments, in conjunction with the administrative department of environmental protection, according to the actual situation in the region, the organization of cleaner production audit. Article cleaner production audit should be the main enterprise, follow the voluntary audit and the state mandatory audit combined with the combination of independent audit and external assistance to audit the combination of principles, according to local conditions, carried out in an orderly manner, focusing on practical results. Chapter II Scope of Cleaner Production Audit Article 6 The cleaner production audit is divided into voluntary audit and mandatory audit. Article 7 The state encourages enterprises to voluntarily carry out cleaner production audits. Pollutant emissions to meet national or local emission standards, enterprises can voluntarily organize the implementation of cleaner production audits, and put forward to further conserve resources and reduce emissions of pollutants target. Article VIII of the following circumstances, shall implement mandatory cleaner production audits: (a) pollutant emissions exceed the national and local emission standards, or the total amount of pollutant emissions exceeded the total emission control targets approved by the local people's government of the polluting enterprises; (b) the use of toxic and hazardous raw materials for the production or the emission of toxic and hazardous substances in the production of enterprises. Toxic and hazardous raw materials or substances mainly refers to the "List of Dangerous Goods" (GB12268), "List of Hazardous Chemicals", "National List of Hazardous Wastes" and "Catalog of Highly Toxic Chemicals" in the highly toxic, highly corrosive, highly irritating, radioactive (excluding nuclear power facilities and military nuclear facilities), carcinogenic, teratogenic and other substances. Article 9 The list of enterprises implementing mandatory cleaner production audits as stipulated in Item 1 of Article 8 shall be put forward by the local administrative department for environmental protection in accordance with the administrative authority to put forward the preliminary list, and then report to the administrative department for environmental protection of provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the central government, municipalities with separate plans, and the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps for approval to be determined, and then release a batch of the list every year, notify the enterprises in writing, and copy the same level of administrative department for development and reform (economic and trade) The competent department of development and reform (economy and trade) at the same level; at the same time, the list will be published in the local major media. Article 8, paragraph 2 of the implementation of mandatory cleaner production audit of the list of enterprises, by the provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the Central Government, municipalities with separate plans and Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps of the administrative department of environmental protection in conjunction with the administrative department of development and reform (economy and trade), combined with the local implementation of cleaner production audit of the actual situation, and analyze the amount of toxic and hazardous raw materials used by the enterprise, or the amount of toxic and hazardous substances emitted, and the possibility of causing environmental impact on the basis of severity. On the basis of the severity of the environmental impact caused by the phase by batch to determine, notify the enterprise in writing, and published in the local major media. Chapter III Implementation of Cleaner Production Audit Article 10 Article 8, paragraph 1 of the implementation of mandatory cleaner production audits of enterprises shall, within one month after the announcement of the list, in the location of the main media to announce the main pollutant emissions. The main contents of the announcement shall include: enterprise name, legal representative, the address of the enterprise, the name of the pollutants discharged, the mode of discharge, the concentration and total amount of emissions, exceeding the standard, exceeding the total amount of the situation. Provincial environmental protection department in accordance with the administrative authority below the main pollutants released by the enterprise to verify the situation. Article XI included in the implementation of mandatory cleaner production audit list of enterprises should be announced in the list within two months after the cleaner production audit. Article 8, paragraph 2 of the implementation of mandatory cleaner production audits of enterprises, the interval between two audits shall not exceed five years. Article XII of the voluntary implementation of cleaner production audits of enterprises can have jurisdiction over the development and reform (economy and trade) administrative department and the administrative department of environmental protection to provide the proposed cleaner production audit plan, and in accordance with the content of the cleaner production audit plan, the procedures for organizing cleaner production audits. Article 13 The cleaner production audit procedures include, in principle, audit preparation, pre-audit verification, audit, implementation program generation, screening and determination, preparation of cleaner production audit report. (A) audit preparation. Training and publicity, the establishment of cleaner production audit by business managers and technical personnel composed of working groups, develop work plans; (B) pre-audit. On the basis of a comprehensive survey of the basic situation of the enterprise, through qualitative and quantitative analysis, to determine the focus of the cleaner production audit and warehousing cleaner production objectives; (C) Audit. Through the production and service process input and output analysis, the establishment of material balance, water balance, resource balance and pollution factor balance, to find out the loss of materials, waste of resources and pollutants generated by the link; (D) the implementation of the program generation and screening. Material loss, resource waste, pollutant generation and emission analysis, put forward the cleaner production implementation program, and the program's initial screening; (E) the implementation of the program to determine. Preliminary screening of cleaner production program for technical, economic and environmental feasibility analysis, to determine the implementation of cleaner production program; (F) the preparation of cleaner production audit report. Cleaner production audit report should include the basic situation of enterprises, cleaner production audit process and results, cleaner production program summary and analysis of benefit forecasts, cleaner production program implementation plan. Chapter IV Organization and Management of Cleaner Production Audit Article 14 The cleaner production audit is mainly carried out by the enterprise's own organization. Do not have the ability to independently carry out cleaner production audits of enterprises, can be entrusted to industry associations, cleaner production centers, engineering consulting units and other consulting services to assist in carrying out cleaner production audits. Article XV to assist enterprises to organize and carry out cleaner production audit of consulting services, should have the following conditions: (a) an independent legal personality; (b) have a familiar with the relevant industry production processes, technology and pollution prevention and management, understanding of cleaner production knowledge, mastery of the cleaner production audit procedures of the technical staff; (c) have a cleaner production audit of the enterprise to provide a fair, just and efficient service (C) has for the enterprise cleaner production audit to provide fair, impartial and efficient service system measures. Article 16 Enterprises included in the implementation of mandatory cleaner production audit list shall, within one year from the date of publication of the list, report the cleaner production audit report to the local administrative department of environmental protection and the administrative department of development and reform (economy and trade). Enterprises directly under the Central Government shall report the cleaner production audit report to the local administrative departments of environmental protection and development and reform (economy and trade), while copying the State Environmental Protection Administration and the National Development and Reform Commission. Article XVII voluntary cleaner production audit of enterprises, can refer to the provisions of Article XVI of these measures to report cleaner production audit report. Article 18 The administrative departments of development and reform (economic and trade) at all levels and the administrative department of environmental protection, should actively guide and supervise enterprises in accordance with the cleaner production audit report proposed in the implementation plan, organization and implementation of cleaner production implementation plan. Article 19 The administrative departments of development and reform (economy and trade) at all levels, the administrative department of environmental protection and consulting services shall keep technical and commercial secrets for the implementation of cleaner production audit enterprises. Article 20 The National Development and Reform Commission, in conjunction with the State Environmental Protection Administration to establish a national cleaner production expert database, cleaner production-oriented directory of key industries and industry cleaner production audit guide, organize cleaner production training, cleaner production audits for enterprises to carry out information and technical support. Local development and reform (economy and trade) administrative departments at all levels, in conjunction with the administrative department of environmental protection can be based on local conditions, organize cleaner production audit training, the establishment of local cleaner production expert database. Chapter V Rewards and Penalties Article 21 For the voluntary implementation of cleaner production audits, as well as cleaner production program after the implementation of the remarkable results of the enterprise, by the provincial level or above, the administrative departments of development and reform (economy and trade) and environmental protection will be commended, and announced in the local major media. Article 22 The administrative departments of development and reform (economy and trade) at all levels in the development and implementation of national key investment plans and local investment plans, should be cleaner production enterprises in the implementation of cleaner production program of energy saving, water conservation, comprehensive utilization, improve resource utilization, pollution prevention and other cleaner production projects as a key area of focus, to increase investment support. Article 23 sewage charges can be used to support the implementation of cleaner production enterprises. In line with the "sewage charges levy and use of management regulations" cleaner production projects, financial departments at all levels, environmental protection departments in the use of sewage charges to give priority to arrangements. Article 24 The Small and Medium Enterprises Development Fund should be arranged according to the need for an appropriate amount to support small and medium enterprises to implement cleaner production. Article 25 Enterprises to carry out cleaner production audit costs are allowed to be included in the enterprise operating costs or related expenses account. Article 26 Enterprises can be established according to the actual situation within the enterprise cleaner production recognition and reward system, the cleaner production audit of the effectiveness of the work of the personnel, to give a certain amount of incentives. Article 27 For enterprises in violation of the provisions of Article 10, in accordance with the "Chinese People's *** and the State Cleaner Production Promotion Law" Article 41 of the provisions of penalties; for enterprises in violation of the provisions of Item 2 of Article 8, in violation of the provisions of Article 16, in accordance with the "Chinese People's *** and the State Cleaner Production Promotion Law" Article 40 of the provisions of penalties. Article 28 If the consulting service organization commissioned by an enterprise fails to carry out cleaner production audits in accordance with the prescribed contents and procedures, and falsifies or provides false audit reports, the development and reform (economic and trade) departments of the provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the central government, municipalities with separate plans and Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps, in conjunction with the competent administrative department of environmental protection, will order it to make corrections, and will publish a list of its names. Causing serious consequences, will be held legally responsible. Article 29 The staff of the relevant administrative department of development and reform (economy and trade) in conjunction with the administrative department of environmental protection shall be penalized in accordance with the corresponding state laws and regulations if they neglect their duties and disclose the technical and commercial secrets of the enterprises, resulting in the economic losses of the enterprises. Chapter VI Supplementary Provisions Article 30 These Measures shall be interpreted by the National Development and Reform Commission and the State Environmental Protection Administration. Article 31 The provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the Central Government, municipalities and Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps can be in accordance with these measures to develop implementation details. Article 32 The military industrial enterprises cleaner production audit can refer to the implementation of these measures.