The American subject "Red Storm", this film is written in the United States strategic nuclear submarines in the state of war story, more realistic, but with a certain commercial flavor. And not in the submarine interior shooting, but ride the scene to do a better job.
"U-571" very trashy commercial film, even the basic shape of the U-boat is not even a whole lot clear, dare to make U-boat movie. What's even more comical is having torpedoes graze the submarine's shell and not explode. It's like the torpedo is a landmine. The depth charges were detonated right next to the submarine, but they couldn't blow up the submarine, and the director didn't have the slightest bit of common sense in physics. 5-6 people drove the U-boat away and fought the war as if the U-boat's automation level was higher than that of the current top-of-the-line submarines.
"K-19 Widowmaker" Harrison Vice Special made a bad movie, completely in the angle of sarcastic irony K-19 to shoot, the K-19 titanium alloy nuclear submarine shot into the knife-shaped bow of the old submarines of World War II. From a military enthusiast's point of view, this movie is a commercial trash movie made by an amateur. It doesn't even get the shape of the K19, and it looks a lot like a political propaganda movie.
The Hunt for Red October The whole story is very good, there are Soviet Typhoon, American Chicken and Soviet K-1, but they are all computerized (the underwater navigation part). The scenery is good, but the Typhoon class is made to look useless and the American Larch class is made to look amazing. The whole confrontation between the submarines was also a bit plausible. But it was barely acceptable