Women born out of wedlock were fined 90 thousand by Quanzhou Health Bureau. What is the basis of the court's decision?

This happened in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, where the regulations are rather strange. It is illegal to give birth outside marriage, and those who give birth need to be fined. The basis of the fine is that he needs to pay a certain amount of social support, which is three to five times the per capita disposable income of the previous year. Now this legal provision has disappeared, and the woman was fined 20 19, involving 93,993 yuan.

It is netizens who feel particularly wonderful when they see this news. Do children born out of wedlock need to pay a fine? There are also girls who give birth out of wedlock, saying that they don't need a fine in their own province, and other provinces may not. After some inquiries, I found that when I learned the truth of the matter, Bian Xiao had made a simple description. Due to the special time and place, it happened in quanzhou county, Guangxi on 20 19. At that time, this place was still implementing the old legal provisions, based on the Regulations on Population and Family Planning of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region. So there is indeed a legal basis for women to be fined. It's not a fine, but netizens don't understand. The law also needs human feelings, so it can't be so casual.

While obeying the law, judges also need to take a look at the reality. Unmarried women don't earn much, and they may be gossiped by neighbors after giving birth. Now they have to pay a fine of nearly 654.38 million yuan, which will also make women's economic pressure heavier. At present, this clause has been cancelled. Can the court return the money to the woman? Although inflation is serious at present, 654.38 million yuan is still a big expense for a family. The essence of law is to serve mankind, not to make mankind suffer for the sake of law.

Nowadays, many people don't want to have children, because the time cost and money cost of giving birth to a child are too high to afford.